Throughout the controversies of the pre-Nicene
age the question felt rather than seen in the background is that of the
Idea of God. The question of Monotheism and
Polytheism which separated Christians from heathen was not so much a
question of abstract theology as of religion, not one of speculative
belief, but of worship. The Gentile was prepared to recognise in the
background of his pantheon the shadowy form of one supreme God, Father
of gods and men, from whom all the rest derived their being. But his
religion required the pantheon as well; he could not worship a
philosophic supreme abstraction. The Christian on the other hand was
prepared in many cases to recognise the existence of beings
corresponding to the gods of the heathen (whether 1 Cor. viii. 5 can be quoted here is open to question).
But such beings he would not worship. To him, as an object of religion,
there was one God. The one God of the heathen was no object of
practical personal religion; the One God of the Christian was. He was
the God of the Old Testament, the God who was known to His people not
under philosophical categories, but in His dealings with them as a
Father, Deliverer, He who would accomplish all things for them that
waited on Him, the God of the Covenant. He was the God of the New
Testament, God in Christ reconciling the world to Himself, manifesting
His Righteousness in the Gospel of Christ to whosoever believed. In
Christ the Christian learned that God is Love. Now this knowledge of
God is essentially religious; it lies in a different plane from the
speculative ἀπορίαι as to God’s
transcendence or immanence, while yet it steadies the religious mind in
the face of speculations tending either way. A God who is Love, if
immanent, must yet be personal, if transcendent, must yet manifest His
Love in such a way that we can know it and not merely guess it. Now as
Christian instinct began to be forced to reflexion, in other words, as
faith began to strive for expression in a theology A
theology which aims at consistency must borrow a method, a philosophy,
from outside the sphere of religion. The most developed system of
Catholic theology, that of S. Thomas Aquinas, borrows its method from
the same source as did Arius,—Aristotle., it
could not but be that men, however personally religious, seized hold of
religious problems by their speculative side. We have seen this
exemplified in the influence of Platonic philosophy on the Apologists
and Alexandrine Fathers. But to Origen, with all his Platonism, belongs
the honour of enthroning the God of Love at the head and centre of a
systematic theology. Yet the theology of the end of the third century
assimilated secondary results of Origen’s system rather than his
underlying idea. On the one hand was the rule of faith with the whole
round of Christian life and worship, determining the religious instinct
of the Church; on the other, the inability to formulate this instinct
in a coherent system so long as the central problem was overlooked or
inadequately dealt with. God is One, not more; yet how is the One God
to be conceived of, what is His
relation to the Universe of γένεσις and φθόρα? and the Son is God, and
the Spirit; how are they One, and if One how distinct? How do we avoid
the relapse into a polytheism of secondary gods? What is—not the
essential nature of Godhead, for all agreed that that is beyond our
ken—but the πρῶτον
ἡμῖν, the essential idea for us to
begin from if we are to synthesise belief and theology, πίστις and γνῶσις?