guidance of the Holy Ghost. The Council looked upon itself, not as revealing any new truth,
but as setting forth the faith once for all delivered to the Saints, its decisions therefore were
in themselves ecumenical, as being an expression of the mind of the whole body of the
faithful both clerical and lay, the sensus communis of the Church. And by the then teaching
of the Church that ecumenical consensus was considered free from the suspicion of error,
guarded, (as was believed,) by the Lord’s promise that the gates of hell should not prevail
against his Church. This then is what Catholics mean when they affirm the infallibility of
Ecumenical Councils. Whether this opinion is true or false is a question outside the scope
of the present discussion. It was necessary, however, to state that these Councils looked
upon themselves as divinely protected in their decisions from error in faith and morals, lest
the reader should otherwise be at a loss to understand the anathematisms which follow the
decrees, and which indeed would be singularly out of place, if the decrees which they thus
emphatically affirm were supposed to rest only upon human wisdom and speculation, instead
of upon divine authority.
Theologians consider that the decisions of Ecumenical Councils, like all juridical decrees,
must be construed strictly, and that only the point at issue must be looked upon as decided.
The obiter dicta of so august a body are no doubt of the greatest weight, but yet they have
no claim to be possessed of that supreme authority which belongs to the definition of the
particular point under consideration.3
The Seven Ecumenical Councils were all called together at the commandment and will
of Princes; without any knowledge of the matter on the part of the Pope in one case at least
(1st Constantinople)4; without any consultation with him in the case of I. Nice, so far as we
know5; and contrary to his expressed desire in at least the case of Chalcedon, when he only
gave a reluctant consent after the Emperor Marcian had already convoked the synod. From
this it is historically evident that Ecumenical Councils can be summoned without either the
knowledge or consent of the See of Rome.
In the history of the Christian Church, especially at a later period in connection with
the Great Schism, much discussion has taken place among the learned as to the relative
powers of a General Council and of the Pope. It will be remembered by everyone that the
3 Vide Vasquez, P. III., Disp. 181, c. 9; Bellarmin., De Concil., Lib. II., cap. xvij.; Veron, Rule of the Cath. Faith,
Chap. I., §§ 4, 5, and 6.
4 See Hefele’s answer to Baronius’s special pleading. Hist. Councils, Vol. I., pp. 9, 10.
5 It should be stated that at the Sixth Synod it was said that I. Nice was “summoned by the Emperor and Pope
Sylvester,” on what authority I know not.
8
Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.