399 and in vain is all that he has said to prove this in his discourse on the wheat and tares.
400
16. To what purpose is it, to object from the parable now mentioned, that the church
ought not to make a distinction between wheat and tares, in their admission of members,
by pretending to discern the difference? When it is so apparent, that there is no pretence to
any proper discerning in the case, nor any other distinction pleaded, than what is made by
a judgment of charity. According to Mr. W—‘s own scheme, churches are obliged to make
a distinction, in the rational judgment they pass, and to admit none, but what they judge to
be true saints; so that those who are wheat, in the eye of their judgment, only are to be ad-
mitted, and such as are tares, in the eye of their judgment, are to be excluded.
17. What is said by Mr. W. of the visible church being the school of Christ, and men
being admitted into it as disciples or scholars, some of them in order to attain grace, (p. 81,
and 83.) is nothing to the purpose, if it be as Mr. W. allows and asserts, that in order to be
admitted into this school, they must be supposed, in a reasonable judgment, to have this at-
tainment already, and make a pretence to it, and a solemn profession of it, and must give
moral evidence that they have it, and must be admitted into the school under no other notion
than that of their being already possessed of it.
18. If it be as Mr. W. expressly says, That persons are not visible saints without a credible
profession, visibility, and moral evidence, not only of moral sincerity, but true holiness, (p.
139.) then all is wholly insignificant and vain, that is said to prove, that the children of Israel
were visible saints without any evidence of such holiness, by reason of the idolatry and gross
and open wickedness of vast multitudes of them, who are yet called God’s people. And so
likewise, all that is said to prove, that the members of the primitive christian church had no
other visibility of saintship than they, because they are grafted into the same olive; and also
all that Mr. W. has said to prove, that many of the members of the primitive churches were
as grossly wicked as they.
19. Since according to Mr. W. the terms of admission to the Jewish ordinances, were
the same as to christian ordinances, the like profession and the same visibility of saintship
required, and no other; as he strenuously asserts, (p. 57. e. p. 61. e. and p. 65. c.) it will
therefore follow from his foregoing concessions and assertions, that none were, by God’s
appointment, to come to the passover, and to have their children circumcised, but such as
openly professed and declared that they were convinced of the truth of God’s word, and
believed it with all their hearts; and professed a hearty consent to the terms of the covenant
of grace: such as covenanted with God with their whole hearts, and gave up all their hearts
and lives to Christ; such as subjected themselves to Christ with their whole hearts, and gave
399 See especially, p. 3.
400 P. 99, 100.
1922
SECTION II. Consequences.