CHURCHMEN AND STATESMEN
seriously complicated by the fact that the heir to the throne
was a professed Roman Catholic.
With so many forces at work the characters of the men
who held the reins of office are naturally hard to estimate.
As usual, we are called upon to deal with the leaders of utterly
different parties ; and according as we praise the conduct of one
of our alumni, so do we implicitly denounce that of another.
Rothes, the champion drinker of a drunken age, was too wicked
to find many admirers, and the subtle Mackenzie of Tarbat
knew too much about bribery and corruption to have many
friends, able though he undoubtedly was. Sir Robert Murray,
on the other hand, distinguished alike in politics and in science,
was so amiable a character that he meets with little denuncia-
tion, despite Clarendon's faint praise. With these exceptions,
however, all the great figures of the time have found both
bitter opponents and zealous defenders.
Sharp is to some a hallowed martyr to the cause of Episco-
pacy ; to others he is a turncoat and a perjurer who was tried
at the bar of his country's conscience, found guilty, and lawfully
executed. Graham of Claverhouse is either " Bonnie Dundee "
who did so brave a " shear-darg " for his unworthy King or"
Bloody Clavers " who rode down the Covenanters in the
south-west, terrifying the children and butchering the men.
Sir George Mackenzie may be alternatively regarded as " Bloody
Mackenzie," the unjust persecutor, or as the able patron of
learning and the tolerant champion of the poor witches.
Cameron and Cargill are denounced as disloyal sectaries or
glorified as heroes of liberty and lions of the covenant, accord-
ing to the judgment or the bias of the historian.
All these St. Andrews men played a great part in the
nation's history ; the characters of all are difficult to judge
rightly ; but that of John Maitland, Duke of Lauderdale, is
probably hardest of all. At first sight he appears as a pitiful
87