But when during your cross-examination Eutyches
replied and said, “I confess that our Lord had two natures before the union but after the union
I confess but one This was the only
compromise of his views which Eutyches could be brought to make at the
synod of Constantinople. Though it was rejected, and did not
hinder his condemnation, it was never met with a direct, categorical
refutation.,” I am
surprised that so absurd and mistaken a statement of his should not
have been criticised and rebuked by his judges, and that an utterance
which reaches the height of stupidity and blasphemy should be allowed
to pass as if nothing offensive had been heard: for the impiety
of saying that the Son of God was of two
natures before His incarnation is only equalled by the iniquity of
asserting that there was but one nature in Him after “the Word
became flesh.” And to the end that Eutyches may not think
this a right or defensible opinion because it was not contradicted by
any expression of yourselves, we warn you beloved brother, to take
anxious care that if ever through the inspiration of God’s mercy the case is brought to a satisfactory
conclusion, his ignorant mind be purged from this pernicious idea as
well as others. He was, indeed, just beginning to beat a retreat
from his erroneous conviction, as the order of proceedings
shows Gestorum ordo,
as before, in chap. 1. A report of the proceedings had
accompanied Flavian’s letter., in so far as when hemmed in by your
remonstrances he agreed to say what he had not said before and to
acquiesce in that belief to which before he had been opposed.
However, when he refused to give his consent to the anathematizing of
his blasphemous dogma, you understood, brother Fraternitas
vestra: or, as the Gk. version apparently took it, “you
and the rest of the brethren” (ἡ ὑμῶν
ἀδελφότης).,
that he abode by his treachery and deserved to receive a verdict of
condemnation. And yet, if he grieves over it faithfully and to
good purpose, and, late though it be, acknowledges how rightly the
bishops’ authority has been set in motion; or if with his own
mouth and hand in your presence he recants his wrong opinions, no mercy
that is shown to him when penitent can be found fault with It will be remembered
that he had been degraded from the priesthood and deprived of his
monastery, as well as excommunicated: he might be reinstated in
all these privileges, the mercifulness of Leo hints, if he recant his
errors.: because our Lord, that true and “good shepherd” who laid
down His life for His sheep S. John x.
11 and 15. and who came to
save not lose men’s souls S. Luke ix. 50., wishes us to
imitate His kindness Pietatis, a
beautiful word, expressing now the Father’s pitying protection,
now the children’s loyal affection, and here the Elder
Brother’s love for the younger and weaker. Cf. n. I. on
chap. iii.; in order that while
justice constrains us when we sin, mercy may prevent our rejection when
we have returned. For then at last is the true Faith most
profitably defended when a false belief is condemned even by the
supporters of it.