If, however, any one desires
that our answer should exactly correspond to the array of his
arguments, let him tell us the utility of such a process. What gain
would it be to my readers if I were to solve the complicated riddle of
his title, which he proposes to us at the very commencement, in the
manner of the sphinx of the tragic stage; namely this ‘New
Apology for the Apology,’ and all the nonsense which he writes
about that; and if I were to tell the long tale of what he dreamt? I
think that the reader is sufficiently wearied with the petty vanity
about this newness in his title already preserved in Eunomius’
own text, and with the want of taste displayed there in the account of
his own exploits, all his labours and his trials, while he wandered
over every land and every sea, and was ‘heralded’ through
the whole world. If all that had to be written down over
again,—and with additions, too, as the refutations of these falsehoods
would naturally have to expand their statement,—who would be
found of such an iron hardness as not to be sickened at this waste of
labour? Suppose I was to write down, taking word by word, an
explanation of that mad story of his; suppose I were to explain, for
instance, who that Armenian was on the shores of the Euxine, who had
annoyed him at first by having the same name as himself, what their
lives were like, what their pursuits, how he had a quarrel with that
Armenian because of the very likeness of their characters, then in what
fashion those two were reconciled, so as to join in a common sympathy
with that winning and most glorious Aetius, his master (for so pompous
are his praises); and after that, what was the plot devised against
himself, by which they brought him to trial on the charge of being
surpassingly popular: suppose, I say, I was to explain all that, should
I not appear, like those who catch opthalmia themselves from frequent
contact with those who are already suffering so, to have caught myself
this malady of fussy circumstantiality? I should be following step by
step each detail of his twaddling story; finding out who the
“slaves released to liberty” were, what was “the
conspiracy σχέσιν. of the initiated” and “the
calling out τάξιν. We have
no context to explain these allusions, the treatise of Eunomius being
lost, which Gregory is now answering, i.e. the Apologia
Apologiæ. of hired slaves,” what
‘Montius and Gallus, and Domitian,’ and ‘false
witnesses,’ and ‘an enraged Emperor,’ and
‘certain sent into exile’ have to do with the argument.
What could be more useless than such tales for the purpose of one who
was not wishing merely to write a narrative, but to refute the argument
of him who had written against his heresy? What follows in the story is
still more profitless; I do not think that the author himself could
peruse it again without yawning, though a strong natural affection for
his offspring does possess every father. He pretends to unfold
there his exploits and his sufferings; the style rears itself into the
sublime, and the legend swells into the tones of tragedy.