The point urged by Orthodoxus throughout is that, since
the Luciferian accepts as valid the baptism conferred by Arian bishops,
it is inconsistent in him not to acknowledge the bishops who have
repented of their Arian opinions. The Luciferian at first (2) in his
eagerness, declares the Arians to be no better than heathen; but he
sees that he has gone too far, and retracts this opinion. Still it is
one thing, he says, (3) to admit a penitent neophyte, another to admit
a man to be bishop and celebrate the Eucharist. We do not wish, he says
(4) to preclude individuals who have fallen from repentance. And we,
replies Orthodoxus, by admitting the bishops save not them only but
their flocks also. “The salt,” says the Luciferian (5),
“which has lost its savour cannot be salted,” and,
“What communion has Christ with Belial?” But this, it is
answered (6), would prove that Arians could not confer baptism at all.
Yes, says the objector, they are like John the Baptist, whose baptism
needed to be followed by that of Christ. But, it is replied, the bishop
gives Christ’s baptism and confers the Holy Spirit. The
confirmation which follows (9) is rather a custom of the churches than
the necessary means of grace.