One
great point of dispute between the Montanists and the Catholics was the
subject of fasts (cf. Hippolytus, VIII. 12, X. 21, who makes it almost
the only ground of complaint against the Montanists). The Montanist
prophetesses ordained two new fasts of a week each in addition to the
annual paschal fast of the Church; and the regulations for these two
weeks were made very severe. Still further they extended the duration
of the regular weekly (Wednesday and Friday) fasts, making them cover
the whole instead of only a part of the day. The Catholics very
strenuously opposed these ordinances, not because they were opposed to
fasting (many of them indulged extensively in the practice), but
because they objected to the imposition of such extra fasts as binding
upon the Church. They were satisfied with the traditional customs in
this matter, and did not care to have heavier burdens imposed upon the
Christians in general than their fathers had borne. Our principal
sources for a knowledge of the dispute between the Montanists and
Catholics on this subject are Tertullian’s de Jejuniis;
Epiphanius, Hær. XLVIII. 8; Jerome, Ep. ad Marcellam
(Migne, Ep. XLI. 3), Comment. in Matt. c. 9, vers. 15;
and Theodoret, Hær. Fab. III. 2.