“Let us see from their own
words what reason they give for the being made man, that is for the
incarnation. If indeed it was that God otherwise not contained in
space, might be contained in space and, as it were under a veil, might
converse with men in the flesh, then their mask and their stage play
are exquisite: not to say that it was possible for Him otherwise to
converse with us, as of yore, in a burning bush and in human form, but if
that He might undo the damnation of sin by taking like to like The
original for ἁρπάσας, “seizing” has ἁγιάσας i.e.
hallowing. then just as He required flesh on account of
the condemned flesh, and a soul on account of the soul, so too he
required a mind on account of the mind, which in Adam not only fell
but,—to employ a term which physicians are accustomed to use
about diseases—was affected with original malady. The
word used is πρωτοπαθεῖν, a late and rare one. Galen uses the correlative
πρωτοπὰθεια
to express a condition distinguished from συμπάθεια For that which did not keep the commandment
was what had received the commandment; and that which dared
transgression was what had not kept the commandment; and that which
specially needed salvation was what had transgressed, and that which
was assumed was what needed salvation; so the mind was assumed. Now
this point has been demonstrated, whether they will or no, by proofs
which are so to say mathematical and necessary. But you are doing just
as though, if a man were to have a diseased eye and a limping foot you
were to cure the foot but leave the eye uncured; or, if a painter had
painted a picture badly, were to alter the picture, but leave the
painter alone, as though he were doing his work well. But if they are
so constrained by these arguments as to take refuge in the statement
that it is possible for God to save man, even without a mind, why then
clearly He might have done so even without flesh, by the mere
expression of His will, just as He works and has worked in the universe
without a body. Away then with the flesh as well as with the mind! Let
there be no inconsistency in your absurdity.”