17. And before the Nicene Council took place,
similar statements were made by Eusebius and his fellows, Narcissus,
Patrophilus, Maris, Paulinus, Theodotus, and Athanasius of [A]nazarba Most
of these original Arians were attacked in a work of Marcellus’s
which Eusebius answers. ‘Now he replies to Asterius,’ says
Eusebius, ‘now to the great Eusebius’ [of Nicomedia],
‘and then he turns upon that man of God, that indeed thrice
blessed person Paulinus [of Tyre]. Then he goes to war with
Origen.…Next he marches out against Narcissus, and pursues the
other Eusebius,’ [himself]. ‘In a word, he counts for
nothing all the Ecclesiastical Fathers, being satisfied with no one but
himself.’ contr. Marc. i. 4. [On Maris (who was not
at Ariminum, and scarcely at Antioch in 363) see D.C.B. s.v.
(2). On Theodotus see vol. i. of this series, p. 320, note 37. On
Paulinus, ib. p. 369.]. And Eusebius of Nicomedia wrote over and above to Arius, to this effect,
‘Since your sentiments are good, pray that all may adopt them;
for it is plain to any one, that what has been made was not before its
origination; but what came to be has a beginning of being.’ And
Eusebius of Cæsarea in Palestine, in a letter to Euphration the
Bishop [Of
Balaneæ, see Ap. Fug. 3; Hist. Ar. 5.], did not scruple to say plainly that
Christ was not true God Quoted, among other passages from Eusebius, in the 7th General
Council, Act. 6. p. 409. [Mansi. xiii. 701 D]. ‘The Son Himself
is God, but not Very God.’ [But see Prolegg. ubi supr.
note 5].. And Athanasius of
[A]nazarba uncloked the heresy still further, saying that the Son of
God was one of the hundred sheep. For writing to Alexander the Bishop,
he had the extreme audacity to say: ‘Why complain of Arius and
his fellows, for saying, The Son of God is made as a creature out of
nothing, and one among others? For all that are made being represented
in parable by the hundred sheep, the Son is one of them. If then the
hundred are not created and originate, or if there be beings beside
that hundred, then may the Son be not a creature nor one among others;
but if those hundred are all originate, and there is nothing besides
the hundred save God alone, what absurdity do Arius and his fellows
utter, when, as comprehending and reckoning Christ in the hundred, they
say that He is one among others?’ And George who now is in
Laodicea, and then was presbyter of Alexandria, and was staying at
Antioch, wrote to Alexander the Bishop; ‘Do not complain of Arius
and his fellows, for saying, “Once the Son of God was not,”
for Isaiah came to be son of Amos, and, whereas Amos was before Isaiah
came to be, Isaiah was not before, but came to be afterwards.’
And he wrote to the Arians, ‘Why complain of Alexander the Pope,
saying, that the Son is from the Father? for you too need not fear to
say that the Son was from God.’ For if the Apostle wrote (1 Cor. xi. 12), ‘All things are from God,’
and it is plain that all things are made of nothing, though the Son too
is a creature and one of things made, still He may be said to be from
God in that sense in which all things are said to be ‘from
God.’ From him then those who hold with Arius learned to simulate
the phrase ‘from God,’ and to use it indeed, but not in a
good meaning. And George himself was deposed by Alexander for certain
reasons, and among them for manifest irreligion; for he was himself a
presbyter, as has been said before.