[Then was read Hadrian’s letter to Tarasius of
Constantinople, which ends by saying that, “our dearly-loved
proto-presbyter of the Holy Church of Rome, and Peter, a monk, a
presbyter, and an abbot, who have been sent by us to the most tranquil
and pious emperors, we beg you will deem them worthy of all kindness
and humane amenity for the sake of St. Peter, coropheus of the
Apostles, and for our sakes, so that for this we may be able to offer
you our sincere thanks.” Compare with this the
statement of the famous historian, Gibbon (Chapter XLIX., N. 79),
“The pope’s legates were casual messengers, two priests
without any special commission, and who were disavowed on their
return. Some vagabond monks were persuaded by the Catholics to
represent the Oriental patriarchs. This curious anecdote is
revealed by Theodore Studites, one of the warmest Iconoclasts of the
age.” And yet to this tissue of false statements Bury, in
his just-published edition of Gibbon (1898), has no note of correction
to make! And this has passed, and will pass, for history among
the overwhelming majority of English readers! Nor does there seem
to be any possible excuse for Gibbon in either particular, the first
statement is proved to be false by the letters of Hadrian, the second
statement is equally disproved by the letters of the “high
priests of the East,” in which it is quite clear that no claim
was set up that they represented the Patriarchs, but the Patriarchates,
which they did, as they proved, in a very real sense. This letter
Gibbon must have seen, if indeed he ever took the trouble to read the
Acts, for it is spread out in full in Actio Secunda and was read at
length to the Council. The letter
being ended (col. 128),]