(γ) Bishops and
Councils. The superiority of councils to single bishops (including
those of Rome, Alexandria, and
Antioch) was questioned by no one in this age. Julius claims the
support, not of authority inherent in his see, but of canons,
and on the basis of them claims a voice in matters affecting the Church
at large, not in his own name, but in that of ‘us all,
that so a just sentence might proceed from all’ (Apol.
c. Ar. 35). Again, just as the judgment of his predecessor
Melchiades and his council was revised at Arles in 314 (Augustin.
Ep. 105. 8), so the case of Athanasius and Marcellus was reheard
at the Council of Sardica three years after the decision of Julius and
his council. The council was the supreme organ of the Church for
legislative, judicial, and doctrinal purposes; had any other of
superior or even equal rank been recognised, or had the authority of
councils themselves been defined a priori by a system of Church
law, the confusion of the fourth century would not have arisen. Whether
or no the age would have gained, we at least should have been the
losers.