tribute to the substantial orthodoxy of Origen. Professor Shedd, in his work on Christian
Doctrine, 3015 pronounces the Nicene Creed “ the received creed-statement among all
Trinitarian Churches.” I assume that this note will be of interest to all theological minds.
For an unsatisfactory and meagre account of primitive creeds, see Bunsen, Hippol., iii. pp.
125–132.
383
III.
(Proceedeth from the Father, p. 344.)
The double procession is no part of the Creed of Christendom; nor did it become fixed
in the West, till, by the influence of Charlemagne, the important but not immaculate
Council of Frankfort ( a.d. 794) completed the work of Toledo, and committed the whole
West to its support. The Anglican Church recites the Filioque liturgically, but explains its
adhesion to this formula in a manner satisfactory to the Easterns. It has no rightful place
in the Creed, however; and its retention in the Nicene Symbol is a just offence, not only to
the Greeks, but against the great canon, Quod semper, etc.
Compare Pearson on the Creed, 3016 and these candid words: “Although the addition
of words to the formal Creed be not justifiable,” etc. Consult the valuable work of Theophanes
Procopowicz, Bishop of Novgorod, which contains a history of the literature of the subject
down to his times. 3017 It is a matter debated anew in our own age, in view of advances to
the Greeks made by Dr. Döllinger and the Old Catholics. Let me refer to a volume almost
equally learned and ill-digested, 3018 written by a clever author who was perverted to Ro-
manism, and returned, after many years, to the Church of England. It bears the marks of
many unreal impressions received during his “Babylonish captivity.” I refer to a work of E.
S. Foulkes.
IV.
(The faith of the Church, p. 347.)
Before the Nicene Council local creeds were in use, all agreeing substantially; all scrip-
tural, but some more full than others. Of these the ancient Symbol of Jerusalem was chief,
and this forms the base of the Nicene Creed. It is here noteworthy that Origen speaks of
“the faith” as something settled and known: clearly, he did not intentionally transgress it.
Bull says, 3019 “Græci Scriptores Ante-Nicæni τὸν κανόνα τῆς πίστεως passim in scriptis
suis commemorant.” See the Jerusalem Creed, on the same page; and note, the Church of
Jerusalem is called by the Second Œcumenical Council ( a.d. 381), “the mother of all the
3015 Vol. ii. p. 438.
3016 pp. 521–526.
3017 Tractatus de Processione Spiritus Sancti, Gothæ, a.d. 1772.
3018 Christendom’s Divisions, London, 1865.
3019 Vol. vi. p. 132, 133.
826
Elucidations.