AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK III.
479
him by a mysterious reply. He said, " Yea." The meaning is, that shall come to pass
which you think shall not be. Your wife
Sara shall bear you a son, and before she
conceives, before he is born, I will give the
boy a name. For, from your error in secretly
laughing, your son shall be called Isaac, that
is laughter. But if you think that God is
seen by those who are pure in heart in this
world, why did Moses, who had previously
said, " I have seen the Lord face to face, and
my life is preserved," afterwards entreat that he might see him distinctly ? And because
he said that he had seen God, the Lord told
him,1 " Thou canst not see My face. For man
shall not see My face, and live." Wherefore
also the Apostle a calls Him the only invisible God, Who dwells in light unapproachable, and
Whom no man hath seen, nor can see. And
the Evangelist John in holy accents testifies,
saying, * " No man hath at any time seen (iod. The only begotten Son Who is in the
bosom of the Father, He hath declared Him." llr Who sees, also declares, not how great
He is Who is seen, nor how much He knows
Who declares ; but as much as the capacity of mortals can receive.
13. And whereas you think he is blessed
who is undefiled in the way, and walks in His
law, you must interpret the former clause by
the latter. From the many proofs I have
adduced you have learnt that no one has been
able to fulfil the law. And if the Apostle,
in comparison with the grace of Christ, reck-
oned those things as filth which formerly,
under the law, he counted gain, so that he
might win Christ, how much more certain
ought we to be that the reason why the grace
of Christ and of the Gospel has been added
is that, under the law, no one could be justi-
fied ? Now if, under the law, no one is
justified, how is he perfectly undefiled in the
way who is still walking and hastening to
reach the goal? Surely, he who is in the
course, and who is advancing on the road, is
inferior to him who has reached his journey's end. If, then, he is undefiled and perfect
who is still walking in the way and advancing in the law, what more shall he have who has
arrived at the end of life and of the law ?
Hence the Apostle, speaking of our Lord,
says that, at the end of the world, when all
virtues shall receive their consummation. He
will present His holy Church to Himself with-
out spot or wrinkle, and yet you think that
Church perfect, while yet in the flesh, which
is subject to death and decay. You deserve
to be told, with the Corinthians,4 " Ye are already perfect, ye are already made rich :
1 Ex. xxxiii. ao.
« t Cor. iv. 8.
' i Tim. i. 17, vi. 16.
ye reign without us, and I would that ye did
reign, that we might also reign with you " — since true and stainless perfection belongs to
the inhabitants of heaven, and is reserved for
that day when the bridegroom shall say to
the bride, '/' Thou art all fair, my love ; and
there is no spot in thee." And in this sense
we must understand the words : 2 " That ye may be blameless and harmless, as children of
God, without blemish " ; for He did not say ye are, but may be. He is contemplating the
future, not stating a case pertaining to the
present; so that here is toil and effort, in that other world the rewards of labour and of
virtue. Lastly, John writes : ' " Beloved, we are sons of God, and it is not yet made manifest what we shall be. We know that
when He shall be manifested, we shall be like
Him : for we shall see Him even as He is."
Although, then, we are sons of God, yet like-
ness to God, and the true contemplation of
God, is promised us then, when He shall
appear in His majesty.
14. From this swelling pride springs the
audacity in prayer which marks the directions
in your letter to a * certain widow as to how
the saints ought to pray. " He," you say,
'"rightly lifts up his hands to God ; he pours out supplications with a good conscience who
can say, ' Thou knowest, Lord, how holy, how innocent, how pure from all deceit,
wrong, and robbery are the hands which I
spread out unto Thee ; how righteous, how
spotless, and free from all falsehood are the
lips with which I pour forth my prayers unto
Thee, that Thou mayest pity me.' " Is this the prayer of a Christian, or of a proud
Pharisee like him who "says in the Gospel,
" God, I thank Thee that I am not as other men are, robbers, unjust, adulterers, or even
as this publican : I fast twice in the week, I
give tithes of all that I possess." Yet he merely thanks God because, by His mercy, he
is not as other men : he execrates sin, and
does not claim his righteousness as his own.
But you say, " Now Thou knowest how holy, how innocent, how pure from all deceit,
wrong, and robbery are the hands which I
spread out before Thee." He says that he fasts twice in the week, that he may afflict his
vicious and wanton flesh, and he gives tithes
1 Cant. iv. 7. y Phil. ii. 15. * i John iii. a.
* See S. Aug. De Gest. Pclag. § 16. The widow was Juliana,
mother to DemetriasUp whom Jerome addressed his l,etterCXXX.
"On the keepine of Virginity 'I. IMa^ius' letter to Demetri.is is found in Jerome s works (Kd. Vail.), vol. xi. col. 15.
6 The whole passage, as quoted by Aujjustin, runs as follows ;
" May piety find with thee a place which it has never found else- where. May truth, which no one now knows, be thy household
friend ; and the law of God. which is despi >'•<! by :ilm" •-.( all men,
be honoured by thee alone." " H<>\v happy, how blessed art thou, if that justice which we are to believe exists only in heaven is
found with thee alone upon earth." Then follow the words
quoted above. • S. Luke xvtii. n.