The
theological genesis of Paul’s system is obscure. The theory of
Newman that he was under strong Jewish influences is largely based upon
the late and apparently quite erroneous tradition that his patroness
Zenobia was a Jewess; see p. 296, note 9a, and Gwatkin, p.
57, and note 3. Harnack regards him as the representative of
‘archaic’ East-Syrian adoptionism such as pervades the
‘Discussion of Archelaus with Manes;’ see Routh,
Rell. v. especially pp. 178–184. But Paul would not have
spoken of Mary as ‘Dei Genetrix,’ p. 128; I cannot see more
in these ‘Acta’ than a naive adoptionism homologous to the
‘naive modalism’ of much early Christian language, but like
it not representative of the entire view of those who use it; we must
also note that the statements of ‘Archelaus’ are coloured
by reaction against the docetism of ‘Manes;’ but Paul may
well have taken up this naive adoptionism, and, by strict
Aristotelian logic, developed it as the exclusive basis of his
system. Whether Paul’s use of the idea of the Logos betrays the
faintest influence of Origen is to me, at least, extremely
uncertain.