S.
Jerome adopts the interpretation given in the text, viz. that S.
Peter’s dissimulation was no sin, but intended as an opportunity
for S. Paul to declare the freedom of the Gentiles from the Jewish Law.
On the other hand, S. Austin considers that he acted through wrong
motives, and sinned in dissembling. In this opinion he is supported by
Tertullian, S. Cyprian, S. Cyril, of Alexandria, S. Gregory and
Ambrosiaster. (Hieron. in loc, et
alibi. August. de Bapt. contr.
Donatist. ii. 2. de Mendacio 8. Tertull. de
Præscript. 23. in Marc. iv. 3. v. 3. Cyprian, Ep. ad
Quint. 71. Cyril. Alex. in Julian. ix. fin. Gregor. in
Ezech. ii. Hom. 6, 9. Ambrosiast. in loc.) S. Austin is influenced in
his judgment of the transaction by an anxiety lest disingenuousness and
duplicity should receive countenance from the apparent example of an
Apostle; S. Chrysostom and S. Jerome by affectionate reverence for the
memory of so great a benefactor and so exalted a saint. Vid. Justinian, in
loco.
[In earlier life
Chrysostom had himself practiced such a “scheme,” as that
which he here attributes to Paul. In order to induce his friend Basil
to be consecrated as a bishop he made on him the (false) impression
that he himself had already been consecrated.] Neander (Life of
Chrysostom p. 22.) says: “In the first book of his work on
the Priesthood Chrysostom defends the principle that a falsehood is
permitted for a good object. An invention which has for its sole object
the advantage of another is rather an οἰκονομία
(the word he uses in expounding our passage.) This lax
view respecting truth was not peculiar to Chrysostom but was consonant
with the prevailing spirit of the Eastern Church. There were a few
exceptions however to this view, among whom were John of Lycopolis in
Egypt, and Basil of Cæsarea who says του κυρίον
διαφορὰν
ψεύδους
οὐδεμαίν
εκφήναντος. Schaff says (Prolegomena p. 8): “Origen,
Jerome and Chrysostom explain the offense of this collision away by
turning it into a theatrical and hypocritical farce, shrewdly arranged
by the Apostle for a purpose. In this respect the modern standard of
ethics is far superior to that of the Fathers and more fully accords
with the spirit of the New Testament.” [We may add that
Chrysostom’s view gains nothing; for to save one Apostle from the
charge of unpremeditated hypocrisy, he makes both guilty of
premeditated hypocrisy.—G.A.]