their new law, for that requires no other than imperfect obedience, or obedience with im-
perfections: and therefore to have obedience attended with imperfections, is no breach of
it; for it is as much as it requires. And they cannot be a breach of their old law: for that, they
say, is entirely abolished; and we never were under it.—They say, it would not be just in
God to require of us perfect obedience, because it would not be just to require more than
we can perform, or to punish us for failing of it. And, therefore, by their own scheme, the
imperfections of our obedience do not deserve to be punished. What need therefore of
Christ dying, to satisfy for them? What need of his suffering, to satisfy for that which is no
fault, and in its own nature deserves no suffering? What need of Christ dying, to purchase,
that our imperfect obedience should be accepted, when, according to their scheme, it would
be unjust in itself, that any other obedience than imperfect should be required? What need
of Christ dying to make way for God’s accepting of such obedience, as it would be unjust
in him not to accept? Is there any need of Christ dying to prevail with God not to do unright-
eously?—If it be said, that Christ died to satisfy that old law for us, that so we might not be
under it, but that there might be room for our being under a more mild law; still I would
inquire, what need of Christ dying, that we might not be under a law, which (by their prin-
ciples) it would be in itself unjust that we should be under, whether Christ had died or no,
because, in our present state, we are not able to keep it?
So the Arminians are inconsistent with themselves, not only, in what they say of the
need of Christ’s satisfaction to atone for those imperfections, which we cannot avoid, but
also in what they say of the grace of God, granted to enable men to perform the sincere
obedience of the new law. “I grant indeed, (says Dr. Stebbing, 130 ) that by original sin, we
are utterly disabled for the performance of the condition, without new grace from God. But
I say then, that he gives such a grace to all of us, by which the performance of the condition,
is truly possible; and upon this ground he may and doth most righteously require it.” If Dr.
Stebbing intends to speak properly, by grace he must mean, that assistance which is of grace,
or of free favour and kindness. But yet in the same place he speaks of it as very unreasonable,
unjust, and cruel, for God to require that, as the condition of pardon, that is become im-
possible by original sin. If it be so, what grace is there in giving assistance and ability to
perform the condition of pardon? Or why is that called by the name of grace, that is an ab-
solute debt, which God is bound to bestow, and which it would be unjust and cruel in him
to withhold, seeing he requires that, as the condition of pardon, which he cannot perform
without it?
130 Treatise of the Operations of the Spirit. 2 edit. P. 112,113.
641
SECTION III. The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen…