41. Those who deny the Council altogether, are
sufficiently exposed by these brief remarks; those, however, who accept
everything else that was defined at Nicæa, and doubt only about
the Coessential, must not be treated as enemies; nor do we here attack
them as Ario-maniacs, nor as opponents of the Fathers, but we discuss
the matter with them as brothers with brothers [See
Prolegg. ch. ii. §8 (2) c.],
who mean what we mean, and dispute only about the word. For, confessing
that the Son is from the essence of the Father, and not from other
subsistence, and that He is not a creature nor work, but His genuine
and natural offspring, and that He is eternally with the Father as
being His Word and Wisdom, they are not far from accepting even the
phrase, ‘Coessential.’ Now such is Basil, who wrote from
Ancyra concerning the faith [Ath.
is referring to the Council of Ancyra, 358.]. For only to say
‘like according to essence,’ is very far from signifying
‘of the essence,’ by which, rather, as they say themselves,
the genuineness of the Son to the Father is signified. Thus tin is only
like to silver, a wolf to a dog, and gilt brass to the true metal; but
tin is not from silver, nor could a wolf be accounted the offspring of
a dog. So
also de Decr. §23. p. 40. Pseudo-Ath. Hyp. Mel. et
Euseb. Hil. de Syn. 89. The illustration runs into this
position, ‘Things that are like, [need] not be the same.’
vid. §39. note 5. On the other hand, Athan. himself contends for
the ταὐτὸν τῇ
ὁμοιώσει, ‘the same in likeness.’ de Decr.
§20. But since they say that He is
‘of the essence’ and ‘Like-in-essence,’ what do
they signify by these but ‘Coessential Vid.
Socr. iii. 25. p. 204. a.b. Una substantia religiose
prædicabitur quæ ex nativitatis proprietate et ex
naturæ similitudine ita indifferens sit, ut una dicatur.
Hil. de Syn. 67.?’ For, while to say only
‘Like-in-essence,’ does not necessarily convey ‘of
the essence,’ on the contrary, to say ‘Coessential,’
is to signify the meaning of both terms, ‘Like-in-essence,’
and ‘of the essence.’ And accordingly they themselves in
controversy with those who say that the Word is a creature, instead of
allowing Him to be genuine Son, have taken their proofs against them
from human illustrations of son and father Here
at last Athan. alludes to the Ancyrene Synodal Letter, vid. Epiph.
Hær. 73, 5 and 7. about which he has kept a pointed silence
above, when tracing the course of the Arian confessions. That is, he
treats the Semi-Arians as tenderly as S. Hilary, as soon as they
break company with the Arians. The Ancyrene Council of 358 was a
protest against the ‘blasphemia’ or second Sirmian
Confession,
with this exception that God is not as man, nor the generation of the
Son as issue of man, but such as may be ascribed to God, and is fit for
us to think. Thus they have called the Father the Fount of Wisdom and
Life, and the Son the Radiance of the Eternal Light, and the Offspring
from the Fountain, as He says, ‘I am the Life,’ and,
‘I Wisdom dwell with Prudence’ (John xiv. 6; Prov. viii. 12). But the Radiance from the Light, and
Offspring from Fountain, and Son from Father, how can these be so fitly
expressed as by ‘Coessential?’ And is there any cause of
fear, lest, because the offspring from men are coessential, the Son, by
being called Coessential, be Himself considered as a human offspring
too? perish the thought! not so; but the explanation is easy. For the
Son is the Father’s Word and Wisdom; whence we learn the
impassibility and indivisibility of such a generation from the Father It is
usual with the Fathers to use the two terms ‘Son’ and
‘Word,’ to guard and complete the ordinary sense of each
other, vid. p. 157, note 6; and p. 167, note 4. The term Son, used by
itself, was abused into Arianism; and the term Word into Sabellianism;
again the term Son might be accused of introducing material notions,
and the term Word of imperfection and transitoriness. Each of them
corrected the other. Orat. i. §28. iv. §8. Euseb.
contr. Marc. ii. 4. p. 54. Isid. Pel. Ep. iv. 141. So S.
Cyril says that we learn ‘from His being called Son that He is
from Him, τὸ ἐξ
αὐτοῦ; from His
being called Wisdom and Word, that He is in Him,’ τὸ ἐν
αὐτῷ. Thesaur. iv.
p. 31. However, S. Athanasius observes, that properly speaking the one
term implies the other, i.e. in its fulness. Orat. iii. §3.
iv. §24 fin. On the other hand the heretics accused Catholics of
inconsistency, or of a union of opposite errors, because they accepted
all the Scripture images together. Vigilius of Thapsus, contr.
Eutych. ii. init. vid. also i. init. and Eulogius, ap. Phot.
225, p. 759.. For not even man’s word is part of
him, nor proceeds from him according to passion De
Decr. §10.;
much less God’s Word; whom the Father has declared to be His own
Son, lest, on the other hand, if we merely heard of ‘Word,’
we should suppose Him, such as is the word of man, impersonal; but
that, hearing that He is Son, we may acknowledge Him to be living Word
and substantive Wisdom.