Athanasius appears to have attempted to bring
about some settlement of the disputes which distracted the Church of
Antioch. The Hist. Aceph. makes him ‘arrange the
affairs’ of that Church, but Sozom. (vi. 5), who copies the
phrase, significantly adds ὡς οἷ& 231·ν
τε ἦν—‘as far as it was
feasible.’ The vacillations (Philost. viii. 2, 7, ix. 3, &c.)
of Euzoius between Eudoxius on the one hand, and the consistent
Anomœans on the other, and the formation of a definite
Anomœan sect, represented in Egypt by Heliodorus, Stephen, and
other nominees of the bitter Arian Secundus (who appears to be dead at
last) probably concerned Athanasius but little. But the breach among the Antiochene Catholics was more
hopeless than ever. The action of Paulinus in ordaining a bishop for
Tyre, Diodorus by name (p. 580 note), shews that he had caught
something of the spirit of Lucifer, while on the other hand we can well
imagine that it was with mixed feelings that Athanasius saw a number of
bishops assemble under Meletius to sign the Nicene Creed. To begin
with, they explained the ὁμοούσιον to
be equivalent to ἐκ
τῆς οὐσίας and
ὅμοιον κατ᾽
οὐσίαν. Now this was no more
than taking Athanasius literally at his word (de Syn. 41
exactly; the confession, Socr. iii. 25, appears to meet Ath. de
Syn. half way: cf. the reference to ᾽Ελληνικὴ
χρῆσις with de Syn. 51),
and there is no reason to doubt that the majority This is
certainly true of men like Athanasius of Ancyra, Eusebius of Samosata,
Pelagius of Laodicea, Titus of Bostra, &c. of
those who signed did so in all sincerity, merely guarding the ὁμοούσιον
against its Sabellian sense (which Hilary de Syn. 71, had
admitted as possible), and in fact, meaning by the term exactly what
Basil the Great and his school meant by it. This is confirmed by the
express denunciation of Arianism and Anomœanism. But Athanasius
may have suspected an intention on the part of some signatories to
evade the full sense of the creed, especially as touching the Holy
Spirit, and this suspicion would not be lessened by the fact that
Acacius signed with the rest. It must remain possible, therefore, that
a clause in the letter to Jovian referred to above, expresses his
displeasure The tract
de Hypocrisi Meletii et Eusebii printed among the
‘dubious’ works of Athanasius may well express the
sentiments of some of his friends of the party of Paulinus on this
occasion. (Tillem. viii. 708.) at the wording of the document. (On the
significance of the confession in question, see Gwatkin, pp. 226
sq., 244, note 1.) We gather from language used by St. Basil at
a later date (Bas. Epp. 89, 258) that Athanasius endeavoured to
conciliate Meletius, and to bring about some understanding between the
two parties in the Church. Meletius appears to have considered such
efforts premature: Basil writes to him that he understands that
Athanasius is much disappointed that no renewal of friendly overtures
has taken place, and that if Meletius desires the good offices of the
Bishop of Alexandria the first word must come from him (probably seven
or eight years later than this date). In justice to Meletius it must be
allowed that Paulinus did his best to embitter the schism by ordaining
bishops at Tyre and elsewhere, ordinations which Meletius naturally
resented, and appears to have ignored (D.C.B. iv. Zeno (3),—where observe that the breach of canons
began with the appointment of Paulinus himself). Athanasius returned to
Alexandria on Feb. 14 (Hist. Aceph.) or 20 (Fest. Ind.),
and Jovian died, by inhaling the fumes of a charcoal fire in the
bedroom of a wayside inn, on Feb. 17.