Polycrates, bishop of Ephesus, is one of the most noted men
connected with the paschal controversy, for the reason that he was the
leader of the bishops of the province of Asia, in which province alone
the Quartodeciman practice was uniformly observed. He was thus the
leading opponent of Bishop Victor of Rome. His relation to the paschal
controversy is brought out more fully in chap. 24. The dates of
Polycrates’ accession to office and of his death are not known to
us; though, of course, with Theophilus, Narcissus, Bacchylus, and the
other bishops concerned in the paschal controversy, he flourished
during the reign of Septimius Severus, while Victor was bishop of Rome.
The only writing of Polycrates of which we know is his epistle to
Victor, a portion of which is quoted by Eusebius, in Bk. III. chap. 31,
and a still larger portion in chap. 24 of this book.
Jerome, in his de
vir. ill. c. 45 speaks in terms of the highest praise of
Polycrates, and quotes from Eusebius the larger fragment, given in
chap. 24, adding, Hæc propterea posui, ut ingenium et
auctoritatem viri ex parvo opusculo demonstrarem. The fact that he
quotes only the passages given by Eusebius would be enough to show that
he quoted from Eusebius, and not directly from Polycrates, even were it
not plain from the statement in his Chron., referred to in note
6, that Polycrates’ epistle was, so far as Jerome knew, no longer
extant. Polycrates himself informs us, in the second fragment given in
chap. 24, that he wrote his epistle with the consent and approval of
all the bishops present at the council summoned by him to discuss the
paschal question. The fact that both Eusebius and Jerome praise
Polycrates so highly, and testify to his orthodoxy, shows how
completely the paschal question had been buried before their time, and
how little the Quartodeciman practice was feared.