It seems
extremely difficult (to recur to the point once more), after reading
this account of St. Martin by Sulpitius, to form any certain conclusion
regarding it. The writer so frequently and solemnly assures us of his
good faith, and there is such a verisimilitude about the style, that it
appears impossible to accept the theory of willful deception on the
part of the writer. And then, he was so intimately acquainted with the
subject of his narrative, that he could hardly have accepted fictions
for facts, or failed in his estimate of the friend he so much admired
and loved. Altogether, this Life of St. Martin seems to bring
before us one of the puzzles of history. The saint himself must
evidently have been a very extraordinary man, to impress one of the
talents and learning of Sulpitius so remarkably as he did; but it is
extremely hard to say how far the miraculous narratives, which enter so
largely into the account before us, were due to pure invention, or
unconscious hallucination. Milner remarks (Church History, II.
193), “I should be ashamed, as well as think the labor ill spent,
to recite the stories at length which Sulpitius gives us.” See,
on the other side, Cardinal Newman’s Essays on Miracles,
p. 127, 209, &c.