§6.
The Council
of Nicæa
.
At the Council of Nicæa,
which met pursuant to an imperial summons in the year 325
A.D
., Eusebius played a very prominent part. A description
of the opening scenes of the Council is given in his
Vita
Constantini
, III. 10 sq. After the Emperor had entered in pomp and
had taken his seat, a bishop who sat next to him upon his right arose
and delivered in his honor the opening oration, to which the Emperor
replied in a brief Latin address. There can be no doubt that this
bishop was our Eusebius. Sozomen (
H. E.
I. 19) states it
directly; and Eusebius, although he does not name the speaker, yet
refers to him, as he had referred to the orator at the dedication of
Paulinus’ church at Tyre, in such a way as to make it clear that
it was himself; and moreover in his
Vita Constantini
, I. 1, he
mentions the fact that he had in the midst of an assembly of the
servants of God addressed an oration to the Emperor on the occasion of
the latter’s
vicennalia
, i.e. in 325
a.d.
On the other hand, however, Theodoret (
H. E
.
I. 7) states that this opening oration was delivered by Eustathius,
bishop of Antioch; while Theodore of Mopsuestia and Philostorgius
(according to Nicetas Choniates,
Thes. de orthod. fid
. V. 7)
assign it to Alexander of Alexandria. As Lightfoot suggests, it is
possible to explain the discrepancy in the reports by
supposing that
Eustathius and Alexander, the two great patriarchs, first addressed a
few words to the Emperor and that then Eusebius delivered the regular
oration. This supposition is not at all unlikely, for it would be quite
proper for the two highest ecclesiastics present to welcome the Emperor
formally in behalf of the assembled prelates, before the regular
oration was delivered by Eusebius. At the same time, the supposition
that one or the other of the two great patriarchs must have delivered
the opening address was such a natural one that it may have been
adopted by Theodoret and the other writers referred to without any
historical basis. It is in any case certain that the regular oration
was delivered by Eusebius himself (see the convincing arguments adduced
by Stroth, p. xxvii. sq.). This oration is no longer extant, but an
idea of its character may be formed from the address delivered by
Eusebius at the Emperor’s
tricennalia
(which is still
extant under the title
De laudibus Constantini
; see below, p.
43) and from the general tone of his Life of Constantine. It was
avowedly a panegyric, and undoubtedly as fulsome as it was possible to
make it, and his powers in that direction were by no means
slight.
That Eusebius, instead of the
bishop of some more prominent church, should have been selected to
deliver the opening address, may have been in part owing to his
recognized standing as the most learned man and the most famous writer
in the Church, in part to the fact that he was not as pronounced a
partisan as some of his distinguished brethren; for instance, Alexander
of Alexandria, and Eusebius of Nicomedia; and finally in some measure
to his intimate relations with the Emperor. How and when his intimacy
with the latter grew up we do not know. As already remarked, he seems
to have become personally acquainted with him many years before, when
Constantine passed through Cæsarea in the train of Diocletian, and
it may be that a mutual friendship, which was so marked in later years,
began at that time. However that may be, Eusebius seems to have
possessed special advantages of one kind or another, enabling him to
come into personal contact with official circles, and once introduced
to imperial notice, his wide learning, sound common sense, genial
temper and broad charity would insure him the friendship of the Emperor
himself, or of any other worthy officer of state. We have no record of
an intimacy between Constantine and Eusebius before the Council of
Nicæa, but many clear intimations of it after that time. In fact,
it is evident that during the last decade at least of the
Emperor’s life, few, if any, bishops stood higher in his esteem
or enjoyed a larger measure of his confidence. Compare for instance the
records of their conversations (contained in the
Vita
Constantini
, I. 28 and II. 9), of their correspondence (
ib
.
II. 46, III. 61, IV. 35 and 36), and the words of Constantine himself
(
ib
. III. 60). The marked attention paid by him to the speeches
delivered by Eusebius in his presence (
ib
. IV. 33 and 46) is
also to be noticed. Eusebius’ intimacy with the imperial family
is shown likewise in the tone of the letter which he wrote to
Constantia, the sister of Constantine and wife of Licinius, in regard
to a likeness of Christ which she had asked him to send her. The
frankness and freedom with which he remonstrates with her for what he
considers mistaken zeal on her part, reveal a degree of familiarity
which could have come only from long and cordial relations between
himself and his royal correspondent. Whatever other reasons therefore
may have combined to indicate Eusebius as the most fitting person to
deliver the oration in honor of the Emperor at the Council of
Nicæa, there can be little doubt that Constantine’s personal
friendship for him had much to do with his selection. The action of the
Council on the subject of Arianism, and Eusebius’ conduct in the
matter, have already been discussed. Of the bishops assembled at the
Council, not far from three hundred in number (the reports of
eye-witnesses vary from two hundred and fifty to three hundred and
eighteen), all but two signed the Nicene creed as adopted by the
Council. These two, both of them Egyptians, were banished with Arius to
Illyria, while Eusebius of Nicomedia, and Theognis of Nicæa, who
subscribed the creed itself but refused to assent to its anathemas,
were also banished for a time, but soon yielded, and were restored to
their churches.
Into the other purposes for
which the Nicene Council was called,—the settlement of the
dispute respecting the time of observing Easter and the healing of the
Meletian schism,—it is not neces
sary to enter here. We have no
record of the part which Eusebius took in these transactions. Lightfoot
has abundantly shown (p. 313 sq.) that the common supposition that
Eusebius was the author of the paschal cycle of nineteen years is
false, and that there is no reason to suppose that he had anything
particular to do with the decision of the paschal question at this
Council.