privative sign does not mark the absence of the bad, but that the word which is the subject
of our inquiry means the essence itself!
Well, if the term imperishable or indestructible is not considered by this maker of an
empty system to be privative of destruction, then by a stern necessity it must follow that
this shape given to the word indicates the very reverse (of the privation of destruction). If,
that is, indestructibility is not the negation of destruction, it must be the assertion of some-
thing incongruous with itself; for it is the very nature of opposites that, when you take away
the one, you admit the other to come in in its place. But as for the bitter task which he ne-
cessitates of proving that the Deity is unreceptive of death, as if there existed any one who
held the contrary opinion, we leave it to take care of itself. For we hold that in the case of
opposites, it makes no difference at all whether we say that something is A, or that it is not
the opposite of A; for instance, in the present discussion, when we have said that God is
Life, we implicitly forbid by this assertion the thought of death in connection with Him,
even though we do not express this in speech; and when we assert that He is unreceptive of
death, we in the same breath show Him to be Life.
“But I do not see,” he rejoins, “how God can be above His own works simply by virtue
of such things as do not belong to Him1210.” And on the strength of this clever sally he calls
it a union of folly and profanity, that our great Basil has ventured on such terms. But I would
counsel him not to indulge his ribaldry too freely against those who use these terms, lest he
should be unconsciously at the same moment heaping insults on himself. For I think that
he himself would not gainsay that the very grandeur of the Divine Nature is recognized in
this, viz. in the absence of all participation in those things which the lower natures are shown
to possess. For if God were involved in any of these peculiarities, He would not possess His
superiority, but would be quite identified with any single individual amongst the beings
who share that peculiarity. But if He is above such things, by reason, in fact, of His not
possessing them, then He stands also above those who do possess them; just as we say that
the Sinless is superior to those in sin. The fact of being removed from evil is an evidence of
abounding in the best. But let him heap these insults on us to his heart’s content. We will
1210 The reasoning, which precedes and follows, amounts to this. Basil had said that the terms ungenerate,
imperishable, immortal, are privative, i.e. express the absence of a quality. Eunomius objects that—No term
expressive of the absence of a quality can be God’s Name: the Ungenerate (which includes the others) is God’s
Name, therefore It does not express a privation. You mean to say, Gregory replies, that Ungenerate, &c. does
not mean not-generated, &c. But what is not not-generated is generated (by your own law of dichotomy);
therefore, Ungenerate means generated; and you prove God perishable and mortal. Here, the fallacy arises from
Gregory’s assuming more than Eunomius’ conclusion: i.e. “the Ungenerate means not only the not-generated,”
changes into “the Ungenerate does not mean,” &c.
580
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.