(b) The Canon of Scripture accepted by
Athanasius has long been known from the fragments of the thirty-ninth
Festal Letter (Easter, 367). The New Testament Canon comprises
all the books received at the present day, but in the older order,
viz., Gospels, Acts, Catholic Epistles, Pauline Epistles (Hebrews
expressly included as S. Paul’s between Thess. and Tim.),
Apocalypse. The Old Testament canon is remarkable in several ways. The
number of books is 22, corresponding to the Alexandrian Jewish
reckoning, not to the (probably) older Jewish or Talmudic reckoning of
24 (the rolls of Ruth and Lam. counted separately, and with the
Hagiographa). This at once excludes from the Canon proper the so-called
‘Apocrypha,’ with the exception of the additions to Daniel,
and of Baruch and ‘the Epistle,’ which are counted as one
book with Jeremiah. The latter is also the case with Lamentations,
while on the other hand the number of 22 is preserved by the reckoning
of Ruth as a separate book from Judges to make up for the exclusion of
Esther. This last point is archaic, and brings Athanasius into
connection with Melito (171 a.d.), who gives
(Eus. H. E. iv. 26. 14, see also vol. 1, p. 144, note 1, in this
series) a Canon which he has obtained by careful enquiry in Palestine.
This Canon agrees with that of Athanasius except with regard to the
order assigned to ‘Esdras’ (i.e. Ezra and Nehemiah, placed by M. at the end), to ‘the
twelve in one book’ (placed by M. after Jer.), and Daniel (placed
by M. before Ezekiel). Now, Esther is nowhere mentioned in the N.T.,
and the Rabbinical discussions as to whether Esther ‘defiled the
hands’ (i.e. was ‘canonical’) went on to the time of
R. Akiba (†135), an older, and even of R. Juda ‘the
holy’ (150–210), a younger, contemporary of Melito (see
Wildeboer, Ontstaan van den Kanon, pp. 58, sq., 65,
&c.). The latter, therefore, may represent the penultimate stage in
the history of the Hebrew canon before its close in the second century,
(doubted by Bleek, Einl.5, §242, but not
unlikely). Here, then, Ath. represents an earlier stage of opinion than
Origen (Eus. H. E. vi. 25), who gives the finally fixed Hebrew
Canon of his own time, but puts Esther at the end. As to the
number of books, Athan. agrees with Josephus, Melito, Origen,
and with Jerome, who, however, knows of the other reckoning of 24
(‘nonnulli’ in Prol. Gal.). Athanasius enumerates,
as ‘outside the Canon, but appointed by the Fathers to be read by
those who newly join us,’ Wisdom, Ecclesiasticus, Esther, Judith,
and Tobit, as well as what is called the Teaching of the Apostles and
the Shepherd. In practice, however, he quotes several of the latter as
‘Scripture’ (Wisdom repeatedly so, see index to this vol.);
‘The Shepherd’ is ‘most profitable,’ and quoted
for the Unity of the Creator (and cf. de Decr. 4), but not as
‘Scripture;’ the ‘Didache’ is not used by him
unless the Syntagma (vide supra, p. lix.) be his genuine
work. He also quotes 1 Esdras for the praise of Truth, and 2 Esdras
once, as a ‘prophet.’ ‘Daniel’ includes Susanna
and Bel and the Dragon.