1857-8] BEETHOVEN'S CHORAL SYMPHONY 173
But it must ba enormously difficult. We had a sort of
explanation handed round, informing us that " the sym-
phony was descriptive of the various manifestations of the
passion of joy." But I don't agree with that. / think it
begins with the striving after joy. There are lovely little
bits like innocent childish happiness, long crescendos be-
ginning in struggle and ending in exultation, then bits
of intense longing and passionate despair all mingled
together in a most fitful, chaotic manner, like many lives ;
but it ends sadly. Then comes the Scherzo, a very long
and important movement, beginning with a dance, and
going on to drinking songs and all sorts of gaiety, some-
times sparkling and graceful, sometimes irresistibly comic ;
every now and then comes the longing, despairing strain
over again, and then it is drowned by the dance music
with the tact marked by the drum and rising to a fortissimo
of mad revelry, and it ends in a grand crash. The Adagio
is most exquisite one of the most lovely, round, rich
harmonies that Beethoven ever wrote, like sailing over
Como in the moonlight, or through Venice in a gondola ;
less broken than the other parts, but getting wilder and
more dreamy at last, and ends sadly too. The last move-
ment begins oddly with broken bits of all the others ; at
last a more solemn strain, like a hymn somewhat, begins
very far away in the basses, and comes nearer and nearer,
till just as you think the whole orchestra will take it up,
the miserable despair comes in with a crash, and then a
pause, and then the bass voice gets up and exhorts them
to throw off their misery and take up the harmony, and
then all the chorus bursts out with Schiller's Ode to Joy.
The last part is solemn and triumphant, very grand not
sweet in its grandeur, as Mozart would have made it, but
echoes of the past storm rolling through it still.
The opening of 1858 was a time of great distress
throughout the silk manufacturing districts, from the
badness of trade. The French treaty of commerce had
much to do with this. My father, true to his Free