725Chapter III. To the argument of the Novatians, that they only deny forgiveness
in the case of greater sins, St. Ambrose replies, that this is also an offence
against God, Who gave the power to forgive all sins, but that of course a more
severe penance must follow in case of graver sins. He points out likewise that
this distinction as to the gravity of sins assigns, as it were, severity to God,
Whose mercy in the Incarnation is overlooked by the Novatians.
727Chapter IV. St. Ambrose proceeds with the proof of the divine mercy, and
shows by the testimony of the Gospels that it prevails over severity, and he
adduces the instance of athletes to show that of those who have denied Christ
before men, all are not to be esteemed alike.
729Chapter V. The objection from the unchangeableness of God is answered
from several passages of Scripture, wherein God promises forgiveness to
sinners on their repentance. St. Ambrose also shows that mercy will be more
readily accorded to such as have sinned, as it were, against their will, which
he illustrates by the case of prisoners taken in war, and by language put into
the mouth of the devil.
732Chapter VI. The Novatians, by excluding such from the banquet of Christ,
imitate not indeed the good Samaritan, but the proud lawyer, the priest, and
the Levite who are blamed in the Gospel, and are indeed worse than these.
733Chapter VII. St. Ambrose, addressing Christ, complains of the Novatians,
and shows that they have no part with Christ, Who wishes all men to be saved.
735Chapter VIII. It was the Lord's will to confer great gifts on His disciples.
Further, the Novatians confute themselves by the practices of laying on of
hands and of baptism, since it is by the same power that sins are remitted in
penance and in baptism. Their conduct is then contrasted with that of our
Lord.
737Chapter IX. By collating similar passages with 1 Sam. iii. 25, St. Ambrose
shows that the meaning is not that no one shall intercede, but that the
intercessor must be worthy as were Moses and Jeremiah, at whose prayers we
read that God spared Israel.
739Chapter X. St. John did not absolutely forbid that prayer should be made for
those who “sin unto death,” since he knew that Moses, Jeremiah, and Stephen
had so prayed, and he himself implies that forgiveness is not to be denied
them.
740Chapter XI. The passage quoted from St. John's Epistle is confirmed by another
in which salvation is promised to those who believe in Christ, which refutes
the Novatians who try to induce the lapsed to believe, although denying them
pardon. Furthermore, many who had lapsed have received the grace of
xxxv