that the controversy was a religious controversy; that that, which I opposed, was what they
always had supposed to be a part of divine truth, a precious and important doctrine of the
word of God; and, that the cause of my opposers was the cause of God. This has led the
more ignorant and less considerate people to look on their zeal against me as virtue, and to
christen even their passions and bitterness in such a cause with sanctified names, and to let
them loose, and prosecute the views of their bitterness and violence without a check of
conscience.
3. They have also had the great advantage of the vast veneration the people had for Mr.
Stoddard’s memory; which was such, that many looked on him almost as a sort of deity.
They were all, (i.e. except the young people,) born and brought up under his ministry, and
had been used from their infancy to esteem his sayings all as oracles. And he, they knew,
maintained that doctrine which I oppose, with great positiveness and zeal, and opposed the
contrary, which I maintain, as an exceedingly pernicious doctrine. Under these circumstances,
I naturally appear as a dangerous opposer of the cause of God, and my teaching and insisting
on the doctrine, which Mr. Stoddard opposed, appears to them a sort of horrid profaneness.
4. Crafty designing men have abundantly filled the ears of the more ignorant with sug-
gestions, that my opinion tends to overthrow all religion, and to ruin the present and future
generations, and to make all heathens, shutting them out of the church of Christ.
5. Not only many of the leading men of Northampton have used their utmost endeavours,
to engage the minds of the common people in this controversy, but they have also been put
forward, by the neighbouring ministers all round. My opposers have also been assisted and
edged on by some at a great distance, persons of note; and some great men in civil authority
have had a great hand in it.
6. It is to be considered, that the contrary opinion to mine, had not only long been es-
tablished in Northampton without so much as one opposer to it; but it had also been fully
and quietly established, for a long time, in all the neighbouring churches and congregations,
and in all the country round, even to a great distance; so that my opinion when first broached,
appeared to the people exceedingly singular. Their views being very narrow, it appeared to
them, that all the world, almost, was against me. And my most crafty opposers improved
this advantage, and abundantly represented me as all alone in my opinion.
7. Many of the people, who at length came to have their spirits much raised, and were
brought to join in violent measures, yet came slowly into it, after being long practised with,
and indefatigable endeavours used, to engage and influence them.
8. There are about twenty heads of families, besides others, women and young people,
who ever appeared openly against the proceedings of the town, and many others have ap-
peared friendly to me. And there is not a little reason to think, that there are many more,
especially women and youths, that would appear so, if they dare. For a person, by appearing
my friend at Northampton, even so much so as openly to discountenance my being turned
275
CHAPTER XIX