Whence arises our obligation to be truly virtuous or holy?—are questions which moral
writers have agitated in all past ages. Some have placed virtue in self-love;—some in acting
agreeably to the fitness of things;—some in following conscience, or moral sense;—some in
following truth;—and some in acting agreeably to the will of God. Those who place or found
virtue in fitness, and those who found it in truth, do but use one synonymous word for an-
other. For they doubtless mean moral fitness, and moral truth; these are no other than vir-
tuous fitness, and virtuous truth. No one would pretend that it is a virtuous action to give a
man poison, because it is fit or direct mode of destroying his life. No person will pretend
that the crucifying of Christ was virtuous, because it was true, compared with the ancient
prophecies.—To found virtue in acting agreeably to conscience, or moral sense, justifies the
persecutions of Christians by Saul of Tarsus, as well as a great proportion of heathenish id-
olatry.—If we found virtue in the will of God, the question arises, Whether the will of God
be our rule, because it is in fact what it is, wise, good and benevolent; or whether it be our
cxciv
rule, merely because it is his will, without any consideration of its nature and tendency; and
whether it would be a rule equally binding, as to observance, if it were foolish and mali-
cious?—Mr. Edwards teaches, that virtue consists in benevolence. He proves that every vol-
untary action, which, in its general tendency and ultimate consequences, leads to happiness,
is virtuous, and that every such action, which has not this tendency, and does not lead to
this consequence, is vicious. By happiness, in this case, he does not mean the happiness of
the agent only, or principally, but happiness in general, happiness on the large scale. Virtuous
or holy benevolence embraces both the agent himself and others—all intelligences, wherever
found, who are capable of a rational and moral blessedness. All actions, proceeding from
such a principle, he holds to be fit, or agreeable to the fitness of things—agreeable equally
to reason, and, to a well-informed conscience, or moral sense, and to moral truth;—and
agreeable especially to the will of God, who “is love,” or benevolence.—In this scheme of
virtue or holiness, Mr. Edwards appears to have been original. Much indeed has been said,
by most moral writers, in favour of benevolence. Many things they had published, which
imply, in their consequences, Mr. Edward’s scheme of virtue. But no one before him had
traced these consequences to their proper issue. No one had formed a system of virtue, and
of morals, built on that foundation.
“4. Mr. Edwards has thrown much light on the inquiry concerning The Origin of Moral
Evil. This question, comprehending the influence which the Deity had in the event of moral
evil, has always been esteemed most difficult and intricate. That God is the author of sin,
has been constantly objected to the Calvinists, as the consequence of their principles, by
their opponents. To avoid this objection, some have holden that God is the author of the
sinful act, which the sinner commits, but that the sinner himself is the author of its sinfulness.
But how we shall abstract the sinfulness of a malicious act from the malicious act itself; and
how God can be the author of a malicious act, and not be the author of the malice, which
409
CHAPTER XXV. Concluding remarks