Chapter
XXXII.—
Symeon, Bishop of Jerusalem,
suffers Martyrdom.
1.
It
is reported that after the age of Nero and Domitian, under the emperor
whose times we are now recording,
870
a
persecution was stirred up against us in certain cities in consequence
of a popular uprising.
871
In this
persecution we have understood that Symeon, the son of Clopas, who, as
we have shown, was the second bishop of the church of Jerusalem,
872
suffered martyrdom.
2. Hegesippus, whose words we
have already quoted in various places,
873
is a witness to this fact also.
Speaking of certain heretics
874
he adds that
Symeon was accused by them at this time; and since it was clear that he
was a Christian, he was tortured in various ways for many days, and
astonished even the judge himself and his attendants in the highest
degree, and finally he suffered a death similar to that of our Lord.
875
3. But there is nothing like
hearing the historian himself, who writes as follows: “Certain of
these heretics brought accusation against Symeon, the son of Clopas, on
the ground that he was a descendant of David
876
and a Christian;
and thus he suffered martyrdom, at the age of one hundred
and twenty years,
877
while Trajan
was emperor and Atticus governor.”
878
4. And the same writer says that
his accusers also, when search was made for the descendants of David,
were arrested as belonging to that family.
879
And it might be reasonably assumed that Symeon was one of those that
saw and heard the Lord,
880
judging from the
length of his life, and from the fact that the Gospel makes mention of
Mary, the wife of Clopas,
881
who was the
father of Symeon, as has been already shown.
882
5. The same historian says that
there were also others, descended from one of the so-called brothers of
the Saviour, whose name was Judas, who, after they had borne testimony
before Domitian, as has been already recorded,
883
in behalf of faith in Christ, lived
until the same reign.
6. He writes as follows:
“They came, therefore, and took the lead of every church
884
as witnesses
885
and as relatives of the Lord. And profound peace being established in
every church, they remained until the reign of the Emperor Trajan,
886
and until the above-mentioned Symeon,
son of Clopas, an uncle of the Lord, was informed against by the
heretics, and was himself in like manner accused for the same cause
887
before the governor Atticus.
888
And after being tortured for many
days he suffered martyrdom, and all, including even the proconsul,
marveled that, at the age of one hundred and twenty years, he could
endure so much. And orders were given that he should be
crucified.”
7. In addition to these things
the same man, while recounting the events of that period, records that
the Church up to that time had remained a pure and uncorrupted virgin,
since, if there were any that attempted to corrupt the sound norm of
the preaching of salvation, they lay until then concealed in obscure
darkness.
8. But when the sacred college
of apostles had suffered death in various forms, and the generation of
those that had been deemed worthy to hear the inspired wisdom with
their own ears had passed away, then the league of godless error took
its rise as a result of the folly of heretical teachers,
889
who, because none of the apostles was
still living, attempted henceforth, with a bold face, to proclaim, in
opposition to the preaching of the truth, the ‘knowledge which is
falsely so-called.’
890
870
Trajan, who reigned from 98 to 117
a.d.
871
Upon the state of the Christians under Trajan, see the next
chapter, with the notes.
872
See chap. 11.
873
Quoted in Bk. II. chap. 23, and in Bk. III. chap. 20, and
mentioned in Bk. III. chap. 11. Upon his life and writings, see Bk. IV.
chap. 8, note 1.
874
In the passage quoted in Bk. IV. chap. 22, §4, Hegesippus
speaks of various heretics, and it looks as if the passage quoted there
directly preceded the present one in the work of Hegesippus.
875
That is, by crucifixion, as stated in §6.
876
It is noticeable that Symeon was not sought out by the imperial
authorities, but was accused to them as a descendant of David and as a
Christian. The former accusation shows with what suspicion all members
of the Jewish royal family were still viewed, as possible instigators
of a revolution (cf. chap. 20, note 2); the latter shows that in the
eyes of the State Christianity was in itself a crime (see the next
chapter, note 6). In the next paragraph it is stated that search was
made by the officials for members of the Jewish royal family. This was
quite natural, after the attention of the government had been
officially drawn to the family by the arrest of Symeon.
877
The date of the martyrdom of Symeon is quite uncertain. It has
been commonly ascribed (together with the martyrdom of Ignatius) to the
year 106 or 107, upon the authority of Eusebius’
Chron.,
which is supposed to connect these events with the ninth or tenth year
of Trajan’s reign. But an examination of the passage in the
Chron.,
where Eusebius groups together these two events and the
persecutions in Bithynia, shows that he did not pretend to know the
exact date of any of them, and simply put them together as three
similar events known to have occurred during the reign of Trajan (cf.
Lightfoot’s
Ignatius, II.
p. 447 sqq.). The year of
Atticus’ proconsulship we unfortunately do not know, although
Wieseler, in his
Christen-Verfolgungen der Cæsaren,
p. 126,
cites Waddington as his authority for the statement that Herodes
Atticus was proconsul of Palestine from 105 to 107; but all that
Waddington says (
Fastes des prov. Asiat.,
p. 720) is, that since
the proconsul for the years 105 to 107 is not known, and Eusebius puts
the death of Symeon in the ninth or tenth year of Trajan, we may assume
that this was the date of Atticus’ proconsulship. This, of
course, furnishes no support for the common opinion. Lightfoot, on
account of the fact that Symeon was the son of Clopas, wishes to put
the martyrdom earlier in Trajan’s reign, and it is probable that
it occurred earlier rather than later; more cannot be said. The great
age of Symeon and his martyrdom under Trajan are too well authenticated
to admit of doubt; at the same time, the figure 120 may well be an
exaggeration, as Lightfoot thinks. Renan (
Les Evangiles,
p. 466)
considers it very improbable that Symeon could have had so long a life
and episcopate, and therefore invents a second Symeon, a great-grandson
of Clopas, as fourth bishop of Jerusalem, and makes him the martyr
mentioned here. But there is nothing improbable in the survival of a
contemporary of Jesus to the time of Trajan, and there is no warrant
for rejecting the tradition, which is unanimous in calling Symeon the
son of Clopas, and also in emphasizing his great age.
878
ἐπὶ
Τραϊανοῦ
καίσαρος καὶ
ὑπατικοῦ
᾽Αττικοῦ
. The nouns being without the article, the phrase is to be
translated, “while Trajan was emperor, and Atticus
governor.” In §6, below, where the article is used, we must
translate, “before Atticus the governor” (see
Lightfoot’s
Ignatius,
I. p. 59).
The word
ὑπατικός
is an adjective signifying “consular, pertaining to a
consul.” It “came to be used in the second century
especially of provincial governors who had held the consulship, and at
a later date of such governors even though they might not have been
consuls” (Lightfoot, p. 59, who refers to Marquardt,
Römische Staatsverwaltung,
I. 409).
879
This is a peculiar statement. Members of the house of David would
hardly have ventured to accuse Symeon on the ground that he belonged to
that house. The statement is, however, quite indefinite. We are not
told what happened to these accusers, nor indeed that they really were
of David’s line, although the
ὡσ€ν
with which Eusebius
introduces the charge does not imply any doubt in his own mind, as
Lightfoot quite rightly remarks. It is possible that some who were of
the line of David may have accused Symeon, not of being a member of
that family, but only of being a Christian, and that the report of the
occurrence may have become afterward confused.
880
This is certainly a reasonable supposition, and the unanimous
election of Symeon as successor of James at a time when there must have
been many living who had seen the Lord, confirms the
conclusion.
881
Mary, the wife of Clopas, is mentioned in
John xix. 25
.
882
See above, chap. 11.
883
See above, chap. 20.
884
See p. 389, note.
885
μ€ρτυρες
. The word is evidently used here in its earlier sense of
“witnesses,” referring to those who testified to Christ
even if they did not seal their testimony with death. This was the
original use of the word, and continued very common during the first
two centuries, after which it became the technical term for persons
actually martyred and was confined to them, while
ὁμολογητής
, “confessor,” gradually came into use as the
technical term for those who had borne testimony in the midst of
persecution, but had not suffered death. As early as the first century
(cf.
Acts xxii. 20
and
Rev. ii.
13
)
μ€ρτυς
was
used of martyrs, but not as distinguishing them from other witnesses to
the truth. See the remarks of Lightfoot, in his edition of Clement of
Rome, p. 46.
886
This part of the quotation has already been given in
Eusebius’ own words in chap. 20, §8. See note 5 on that
chapter.
887
ἐπὶ
τῷ αὐτῷ
λόγῳ
, that is, was
accused for the same reason that the grandsons of Judas (whom
Hegesippus had mentioned just before) were; namely, because he belonged
to the line of David. See chap. 20; but compare also the remarks made
in note 10, above.
888
ἐπὶ
᾽Αττικοῦ τοῦ
ὑπατικοῦ
. See above, note 9.
889
On the heretics mentioned by Hegesippus, see Bk. IV. chap.
22.
890
τὴν
ψευδόνυμον
γνῶσιν
;
1 Tim. vi.
20
. A
few
mss.
, followed by Stephanus, Valesius (in
his text), Closs, and Crusè, add the words (in substance):
“Such is the statement of Hegesippus. But let us proceed with the
course of our history.” The majority of the
mss.
, however, endorsed by Valesius in his notes, and
followed by Burton, Heinichen, and most of the editors, omit the words,
which are clearly an interpolation.