16. The connexion is somewhat doubtful. Chrys. (in Cramer’s Catena), Œc., Bengel, Gerh., De Wette, join ὡςἐλεύθεροι with ὑποτάγητε above, 1 Peter 2:13; Bed[8], Luther, Calv., Hammond, Wiesinger, with ἀγαθοποιοῦντας, 1 Peter 2:15; Steiger, Huther, with the following, 1 Peter 2:17. This latter seems quite untenable, as carrying no application on from 1 Peter 2:16 to 1 Peter 2:17. No one would think of pleading his freedom as an excuse for not honouring all, or for not loving the brethren, or for not fearing God: or indeed for not, in some sense, honouring the King. But in a matter of subjection, such ἐλευθερία might be and often is made a cloak for disobedience.
Connecting then ὡςἐλεύθ. with what has preceded, which of the other connexions are we to take? That with ὑποτάγητε seems too distant: it may certainly be said that 1 Peter 2:17 brings in again the general duty in its most simple form: but even thus we can hardly account for the parenthetical 1 Peter 2:15, so unparenthetical in its aspect and construction. Whereas if we join ὡςἐλεύθ. to 1 Peter 2:15, we obtain, as Wiesinger well argues, an epexegesis which that verse seems to need,—for it is almost a truism that we are to accomplish the φιμοῦν by ἀγαθοποιεῖν, unless some explanation be given of the particular circumstances under which this is to take place. I regard then 1 Peter 2:16 as an epexegesis of 1 Peter 2:15, not carrying on the construction with an accus. but with a nom. as already in 1 Peter 2:12, and indeed even more naturally here, because not the act consequent on ἀγαθοποιεῖν, as there on ἀπέχεσθαι, is specified, but the antecedent state and Christian mode of ἀγαθοποιεῖν. As free (children of God, His family and people, His kingly priesthood: not merely free from the law, or free from sin, or free from earthly subjection, but generally and abstractedly free—Christ’s freed men), and not as ( ὡς belongs to ἔχοντες, not to ἐπικάλυμμα ) having (cf. above, 1 Peter 2:12) your freedom (for) a veil (reff.) of your evil intent (the τῆς, hypothetical: of the evil intent which using your freedom as a veil would necessarily presuppose), but as God’s (emphatic) servants (and therefore bound to submit yourselves to that which God ordains).
[8] Bede, the Venerable, 731; Bedegr, a Greek MS. cited by Bede, nearly identical with Cod. “E,”mentioned in this edn only when it differs from E.