26. You go on to say, “The servant of God should
utter from his lips no bitterness, but ever that which is sweet and
pleasant”; and as though a servant of God were one thing, a
doctor and priest of the Church another, forgetting what was previously
laid down, you say in another heading, “A priest or doctor ought
to watch the actions of all, and confidently rebuke sinners, lest he be
responsible for them and their blood be required at his hands.”
And, not satisfied with saying it once, you repeat it, and inculcate
that, “A priest or doctor should flatter no one, but boldly
rebuke all, lest he destroy both himself and those who hear him.”
Is there so little harmony in one and the same work that you do not
know what you have previously said? For if the servant of God ought to
utter no bitterness from his mouth, but always that which is sweet and
pleasant, it follows either that a priest and doctor will not be
servants of God who ought to confidently rebuke sinners, and flatter no
one, but boldly reprove all: or, if a priest and a doctor are not only
servants of God, but have the chief place among His servants, it is
idle to reserve smooth and pleasant speeches for the servants of God,
for these are characteristic of heretics and of them who wish to
deceive; as the Apostle says, Rom. xvi. 18. “They
that are such serve not our Lord Christ but their own belly, and by
their smooth and fair speech they beguile the hearts of the
innocent.” Flattery is always insidious, crafty, and smooth. And
the flatterer is well described by the philosophers as “a
pleasant enemy.” Truth is bitter, of gloomy visage and
wrinkled brow, and distasteful to those who are rebuked. Hence the
Apostle says, Gal. iv. 16. “Am I
become your enemy, because I tell you the truth?” And the comic
poet tells us that “Obsequiousness is the mother of friendship,
truth of enmity.” Wherefore we also eat the Passover with bitter
herbs, and the chosen vessel teaches that the Passover should be kept
with truth and sincerity. Let truth in our case be plain speaking, and
bitterness will instantly follow.