though he should say, he did not think himself converted. For I call that a profession of
godliness, which is a profession of the great things wherein godliness consists, and not a
profession of his own opinion of his good estate.”(
Northampton, May 7, 1750.
In like manner, I explained my opinion, very particularly and expressly, before the
council that determined my separation from my people, and before the church, in a very
public manner in the meeting-house, many people being present, near a year before Mr.
W—‘s book was published. And to make it the more sure, that what I maintained might be
well observed, I afterwards sent in the foregoing extract of my letter to Mr. Clark of
Salem—Village, into the council. And, as I was informed, it was particularly taken notice of
in the council, and handed round among them, to be read by them.
The same council, having heard that I had made certain draughts of the covenant, or
forms of a public profession of religion, which I stood ready to accept of from the candidates
for communion, they, for their further information, sent for them. Accordingly I sent them
four distinct draughts or forms, which I had drawn up about a twelvemonth before, (near
two years before the publishing of Mr. W—‘s book,) as what I stood ready to accept of (any
one of them) rather than contend and break with my people.—The two shortest of those
forms were as follows.
One of them was;
“I hope, I do truly find a heart to give up myself wholly to God, according to the tenor
of that covenant of grace which was sealed in my baptism, and to walk in a way of that
obedience to all the commandments of God, which the covenant of grace requires, as long
as I live.”
The other,
“I hope, I truly find in my heart a willingness to comply with all the commandments of
God, which require me to give up myself wholly to him, and to serve him with my body and
my spirit; and do accordingly now promise to walk in a way of obedience to all the com-
mandments of God, as long as I live.”
Now the reader is left to judge, whether I insist, as Mr. W. represents, that persons must
not be admitted without the highest evidence a man can give of sincerity.
II. Mr. W. is abundant in suggesting and insinuating to his readers, that the opinion
laid down in my book is, That persons ought not to be admitted to a communion without
an absolute and peremptory determination in those who admit them, that they are truly
godly; because I suppose it to be necessary, that there should be a positive judgment in their
favour.
of that opinion, nor his judging himself unconverted, would hinder my receiving him who exhibited proper
evidence to the church of his being a convert.
1904
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.