454 JEROME.
them, they may fall ; and that a man always
occupies a middle place, so that he may slip
from the height of virtue into vice, or may
rise from vice to virtue ; and that he is
never safe, but must dread shipwreck even
in fair weather ; and, therefore, that a man
cannot be without sin. Solomon says,
1 " There is not a righteous man upon earth
that doeth good and sinneth not" ; and like-
wise in the book of Kings : 2 " There is no
man that sinneth not." So, also, the blessed
David says:3 "Who can understand his errors ? Cleanse Thou me from hidden faults,
and keep back Thy servant from presumptuous
sins." And again:4 "Enter not into judg- ment with Thy servant, for in Thy sight shall
no man living be justified." Holy Scripture is full of passages to the same effect.
13. C. But what answer will you give to the
famous declaration of John the Evangelist :
6" We know that whosoever is begotten of God sinneth not ; but the begetting of God keepeth
him, and the evil one toucheth him not. We
know that we are of God, and the whole
world lieth in the evil one ? " A. I will requite like with like, and will
show that, according to you, the little epistle
of the Evangelist contradicts itself. For, if
whosoever is begotten of God sinneth not
because His seed abideth in him, and he can-
not sin, because he is born of God, how is it
that the writer says in the same place: 6"If we say that we have no sin, we deceive our-
selves, and the truth is not in us?" You cannot explain. You hesitate and are con-
fused. Listen to the same Evangelist telling
us that 7"If we confess our sins, he is faith- ful and just to forgive us our sins, and
to cleanse us from all unrighteousness." We are then righteous when we confess
that we are sinners, and our righteous-
ness depends not upon our own merits, but
on the mercy of God, as the Holy Scripture
says, 8 " The righteous man accuseth himself
when he beginneth to speak," and elsewhere,
"Tell thy sins that thou mayest be justified.'
10 " God hath phut up all under sin, that He
may have mercy upon all." And the highest righteousness of man is this — whatever virtue he may be able to acquire, not to think it his
own, but the gift of God. He then who is
born of God does not sin, so long as the seec
of God remains in him, and he cannot sin, be-
cause he is born of God. But seeing that
while the householder slept, an enemy sowec
tares, and that when we know not, a sower by
night scatters in the Lord's field darnel anc
1 F.ccles. vii. 21.
4 Ps. cxliii. 2.
7 i John i. g.
9 Is. xliii. 26, Sept.
2 2 Chron vi. 36. 3 Ps. xix. 12, 13.
8 i John v. 18, 19. 6 i John i. 8.
8 Prov. xviii. 17, Vulg. nearly. 10 Rom. xi. 32.
vild oats among the good corn, this parable
of the householder in the Gospel should excite
our fears. He cleanses his floor, and gathers
the wheat into his garner, but leaves the chaff
to be scattered by the winds, or burned by the
Ire. And so we read in Jeremiah,1 " What is
the chaff to the wheat? saith the Lord." The chaff, moreover, is separated from the wheat
at the end of the world, a proof that, while we
are in the mortal body, chaff is mixed with the
wheat. But if you object, and ask why did
the Apostle say "and he cannot sin, because
he is born of God," I reply by asking you what becomes of the reward of his choice ?
For if a man does not sin because he cannot
sin, free will is destroyed, nnd goodness can-
not possibly be due to his efforts, but must be
part of a nature unreceptive of evil.
14. C. The task I set you just now was an
easy one by way of practice for something
more difficult. What have you to say to my
next argument ? Clever as you are, all your skill will not avail to overthrow it. I shall
first quote from the Old Testament, then from
the New. Moses is the chief figure in the Old
Testament, our Lord and Saviour in the New.
Moses says to the people, 2 " Be perfect in the
sight of the Lord your God." And the Sav- iour bids the Apostles 3 " Be perfect as your
heavenly Father is perfect." Now it was either possible for the hearers to do what Moses and
the Lord commanded, or, if it be impossible,
the fault does not lie with them who cannot
obey, but with Him who gave impossible commands.
A. This passage to the ignorant, and to those who are unaccustomed to meditate on
Holy Scripture, and who neither know nor
use it, does appear at first sight to favour your
opinion. But when you look into it, the diffi-
culty soon disappears. And when you com-
pare passages of Scripture with others, that,
the Holy Spirit may not seem to contradict
Himself with changing place and time, ac-
cording to what is written, 4 " Deep calleth
unto deep at the noise of thy water spouts," the truth will show itself, that, is, that Christ
did give a possible command when He said :>,
"Be ye perfect as your heavenly Father is
perfect," and yet that the Apostles were not
perfect. C. I am not talking of what the Apostles
did, but of what Christ commanded. And
the fault does not lie with the giver of the
command, but with the hearers of it, because
we cannot admit the justice of him who com- mands without conceding the possibility of
doing what is commanded.
A. Good ! Don't tell me then that a man
i Jer. xxiii. 28. 3 S. Matt. v. 48
2 Dent xviii. 13. * Ps. xli. 7,