SECT. IX.
Of the Connexion of the Acts of the Will with the Dictates of the Understanding.
It is manifest, that no Acts of the Will are contingent, in such a sense as to be without
all necessity, or so as not to be necessary with a necessity of consequence and Connexion;
because every Act of the Will is some way connected with the Understanding, and is as the
greatest apparent good is, in the manner which has already been explained; namely, that
the soul always wills or chooses that which, in the present view of the mind, considered in
the whole of that view, and all that belongs to it, appears most agreeable. Because, as was
observed before, nothing is more evident than that, when men act voluntarily, and do what
they please, then they do what appears most agreeable to them; and to say otherwise, would
25
be as much as to affirm, that men do not choose what appears to suit them best, or what
seems most pleasing to them; or that they do not choose what they prefer. Which brings
the matter to a contradiction.
And as it is very evident in itself, that the Acts of the Will have some Connexion with
the Dictates or views of the Understanding, so this is allowed by some of the chief of the
Arminian writers; particularly by Dr. Whitby and Dr. Samuel Clark. Dr. Turnbull, though
a great enemy to the doctrine of necessity, allows the same thing. In his Christian Philosophy,
(p. 196.) he with much approbation cites another philosopher, as of the same mind, in these
words: “No man (says an excellent philosopher) sets himself about any thing, but upon
some view or other, which serves him for a reason for what he does; and whatsoever faculties
he employs, the Understanding, with such light as it has, well or ill formed, constantly leads;
and by that light, true or false, all her operative powers are directed. The Will itself, how
absolute and incontrollable soever it may be thought, never fails in its obedience to the
Dictates of the Understanding. Temples have their sacred images; and we see what influence
they have always had over a great part of mankind; but in truth, the ideas and images in
men’s minds are the invisible powers that constantly govern them; and to these they all pay
universally a ready submission.” But whether this be in a just consistence with themselves,
and their own notions of liberty, I desire may now be impartially considered.
Dr. Whitby plainly supposes, that the Acts and determinations of the Will always follow
the Understanding’s view of the greatest good to be obtained, or evil to be avoided; or, in
other words, that the determinations of the Will constantly and infallibly follow these two
things in the Understanding: 1. The degree of good to be obtained, and evil to be avoided,
proposed to the Understanding, and apprehended, viewed, and taken notice of by it. 2. The
degree of the Understanding’s apprehension of that good or evil; which is increased by atten-
tion and consideration. That this is an opinion in which he is exceeding peremptory, (as he
is in every opinion which he maintains in his controversy with the Calvinists,) with disdain
SECTION IX. Of the Connexion of the Acts of the Will with the Dictates of the Understanding.
577
SECTION IX. Of the Connexion of the Acts of the Will with the Dictates…