Stephanus, Stroth, Burton, Schwegler, Laemmer, and Heinichen,
following two important mss. and the
translation of Rufinus, omit the words παῖδα ὄντα
“while a boy.” But the words are found in
all the other codices (the chief witnesses of two of the three great
families of mss. being for them) and in
Nicephorus. The manuscript authority is therefore overwhelmingly in
favor of the words, and they are adopted by Valesius, Zimmermann, and
Crusè. Rufinus is a strong witness against the words but, as
Redepenning justly remarks, having inserted this chapter, as he did, in
the midst of the description of Origen’s early years (see note
1), the words παῖδα ὄντα
would be quite superfluous and even out of place, and
hence he would naturally omit them. So far as the probabilities of the
insertion or omission of the words in the present passage are
concerned, it seems to me more natural to suppose that a copyist,
finding the words at this late stage in the account of Origen’s
life, would be inclined to omit them, than that not finding them there
he should, upon historical grounds (which he could have reached only
after some reflection), think that they ought to be inserted. The
latter would be not only a more difficult but also a much graver step
than the former. There seems, then, to be no good warrant for omitting
these words. We learn from chap. 3 that he took charge of the
catechetical school when he was in his eighteenth year, within a year
therefore after the death of his father. And we learn that before he
took charge of the school, all who had given instruction there had been
driven away by the persecution. Clement, therefore, must have left
before Origen’s eighteenth year, and hence the latter must have
studied with him before the persecution had broken up the school, and
in all probability before the death of Leonides. In any case,
therefore, he was still a boy when under Clement, and even if we omit
the words—“while a boy”—here, we shall not be
warranted in putting his student days into the period of his maturity,
as some would do. Upon this subject, see Redepenning, I. p. 431 sqq.,
who adduces still other arguments for the position taken in this note
which it is not necessary to repeat here.