But it would be giving an entirely unfair impression of
the matter to the reader were he left to suppose that this necessity
for Rome’s confirmation sprang necessarily from any idea of
Rome’s infallibility. So far as appears from any extant
document, such an idea was as unknown in the whole world then as it is
in four of the five patriarchates to-day. And it should be borne
in mind that the confirmation by the Emperor was sought for and spoken
of in quite as strong, if not stronger, terms. Before passing to
a particular examination of what relation each of the Councils bore to
the Roman See, it may be well to note that while as an historical fact
each of the Seven Ecumenical Councils did eventually find acceptance at
Rome, this fact does not prove that such acceptance is necessary in the
nature of things. If we can imagine a time when Rome is not in
communion with the greater part of the West, then it is quite possible
to imagine that an Ecumenical Council could be held whose decrees would
(for the time being) be rejected by the unworthy occupant of the
Apostolic See. I am not asserting that such a state of affairs is
possible from a theological standpoint, but merely stating an
historical contingency which is perfectly within the range of
imagination, even if cut off from any practical possibility by the
faith of some.