For after saying that the
Only-begotten God is not the same in essence with the true Father, and
after sophistically inferring this from the opposition between generate
and ungenerate, they work in silence to the conclusion, their impiety
prevailing by the natural course of inference. And as the poisoner
makes his drug acceptable to his victim by sweetening its deadliness
with honey, and, as for himself, has only to offer it, while the drug
insinuating itself into the vitals without further action on the part
of the poisoner does its deadly work,—so, too, do our opponents
act. For qualifying their pernicious teaching with their sophistical
refinements, as with honey, when they have infused into the mind of the
hearer the venomous fallacy that God the Only-begotten is not very God,
they cause all the rest to be inferred without saying a word. For when
they are persuaded that He is not truly God, it follows as a matter of
course that no other Divine attribute is truly applicable.
For if He is truly neither Son nor God, except by an abuse of terms,
then the other names which are given to Him in Holy Scripture are a
divergence from the truth. For the one thing cannot be predicated of
Him with truth, and the other be destitute of it; but they must needs
follow one another, so that, if He be truly God, it follows that He is
Judge and King, and that His several attributes are such as they are
described, while, if His godhead be falsely asserted, neither will the
truth hold respecting any of His other attributes. They, then, having
been deceived into the persuasion that the attribute of Godhead is
falsely applied to the Only-begotten, it follows that He is not rightly
the object of worship and adoration, or, in fact, of any of the honours
that are paid to God. In order, then, to render their attack upon the
Saviour efficacious, this is the blasphemous method that they have
adopted. There is no need, they urge, of looking at the collective
attributes by which the Son’s equality in honour and dignity with
the Father is signified, but from the opposition between generate and
ungenerate we must argue a distinctive difference of nature; for the
Divine nature is that which is denoted by the term ungenerate. Again,
since all men of sense regard it as impracticable to indicate the
ineffable Being by any force of words, because neither does our
knowledge extend to the comprehension of what transcends knowledge, nor
does the ministry of words have such power in us as to avail for the
full enunciation of our thought, where the mind is engaged on anything
eminently lofty and divine,—these wise folk, on the contrary,
convicting men in general of want of sense and ignorance of logic,
assert their own knowledge of such matters, and their ability to impart
it to whomsoever they will; and accordingly they maintain that the
divine nature is simply ungeneracy per se, and declaring this to
be sovereign and supreme, they make this word comprehend the whole
greatness of Godhead, so as to necessitate the inference that if
ungeneracy is the main point of the essence, and the other divine
attributes are bound up with it, viz. Godhead, power, imperishableness
and so on—if (I say) ungeneracy mean these, then, if this
ungeneracy cannot be predicated of something, neither can the rest. For
as reason, and risibility, and capacity of knowledge are proper to man,
and what is not humanity may not be classed among the properties of his
nature, so, if true Godhead consists in ungeneracy, then, to whatsoever
thing the latter name does not properly belong, no one at all of the
other distinguishing attributes of Godhead will be found in it. If,
then, ungeneracy is not predicable of the Son, it follows that no other
of His sublime and godlike attributes are properly ascribed to Him.
This, then, they define as a right comprehension of the divine
mysteries—the rejection of the Son’s Godhead—all but
shouting in the ear of those who would listen to them; “To you it
is given to be perfect in knowledge Eunomius arrived at the same conclusions as Arius, but by a
different path. “The true name of God is ᾽Αγέννητος, and this name is incommunicable to other
essences.” He attacked both the Arians and the orthodox. The
former he reproached for saying that we can know God only in part: the
latter for saying that we know God only through the Universe, and the
Son, the Author of the Universe. He maintained, on the contrary, that
it was unworthy of a Christian to profess the impossibility of knowing
the Divine Nature, and the manner in which the Son is generated.
Rather, the mind of the believer rises above every sensible and
intelligible essence, and does not stop even at the generation of the
Son, but mounts above, aspiring to possess the First Cause. Is this
bold assertion, Denys (De la Philosophie d’Origène,
p. 446) asks, so contrary as it is to the teaching of the Fathers, a
reminiscence of Origen, or a direct borrowing from Plato or the
Neoplatonists? The language in which it is expressed certainly belongs
to the latter (ὑποκύψας,
ἐπέκεινα,
πόθος, τὸ
πρῶτον,
γλιχόμενος): but Origen himself, less wise in this matter than
Clement, was not far from believing that there was a Way above Him Whom
S. John calls the Way, a Light above the Light that “lighteth
every man that cometh into the world,” an “Eternal
Gospel” above the present Gospel; and that these were not
inaccessible at once to human creatures. Only they could not be reached
in themselves, and without a Mediator, until Christ, having
vanquished His enemies, had given back the kingdom to the Father, and
God was “all in all.”—This doctrine of the
᾽Αγέννητος, then, made it necessary for Basil and Gregory to throw
their whole weight against Eunomius, rather than against Macedonius,
who, as inconsequent through not dealing alike with the Second and
Third Person, could not be so dangerous an enemy., if only you
believe not in God the Only-begotten as being very God, and honour not
the Son as the Father is honoured, but regard Him as by nature a
created being, not Lord and Master, but slave and subject.” For
this is the aim and object of their design, though the blasphemy is
cloaked in different terms.