by your letters you prove yourself to possess, and which I greatly love in you as God’s gift,
you will see that he has not hesitated to wound by his most injurious language almost the
whole Church of Christ, from the rising of the sun to its going down. Nay, I may say not
almost, but absolutely, the whole Church. For he is found to have not even spared the Roman
Christians, whose custom he seems to himself to defend; but he is not aware how the force
of his invectives recoils upon them, for it has escaped his observation. For when arguments
266
to prove the obligation to fast on the seventh day of the week fail him, he enters on a vehe-
ment blustering protest against the excesses of banquets and drunken revelries, and the
worst licence of intoxication, as if there were no medium between fasting and rioting. Now
if this be admitted, what good can fasting on Saturday do to the Romans? since on the other
days on which they do not fast they must be presumed, according to his reasoning, to be
gluttonous, and given to excess in wine. If, therefore, there is any difference between loading
the heart with surfeiting and drunkenness, which is always sinful, and relaxing the strictness
of fasting, with due regard to self-restraint and temperance on the other, which is done on
the Lord’s day without censure from any Christian,—if, I say, there is a difference between
these two things, let him first mark the distinction between the repasts of saints and the ex-
cessive eating and drinking of those whose god is their belly, lest he charge the Romans
themselves with belonging to the latter class on the days on which they do not fast; and then
let him inquire, not whether it is lawful to indulge in drunkenness on the seventh day of the
week, which is not lawful on the Lord’s day, but whether it is incumbent on us to fast on
the seventh day of the week, which we are not wont to do on the Lord’s day.
4. This question I would wish to see him investigate, and resolve in such a manner as
would not involve him in the guilt of openly speaking against the whole Church diffused
throughout the world, with the exception of the Roman Christians, and hitherto a few of
the Western communities. Is it, I ask, to be endured among the entire Eastern Christian
communities, and many of those in the West, that this man should say of so many and so
eminent servants of Christ, who on the seventh day of the week refresh themselves soberly
and moderately with food, that they “are in the flesh, and cannot please God;” and that of
them it is written, “Let the wicked depart from me, I will not know their way;” and that they
make their belly their god, that they prefer Jewish rites to those of the Church, and are sons
of the bondwoman; that they are governed not by the righteous law of God, but by their
own good pleasure, consulting their own appetites instead of submitting to salutary restraint;
also that they are carnal, and savour of death, and other such charges, which if he had uttered
against even one servant of God, who would listen to him, who would not be bound to turn
away from him? But now, when he assails with such reproachful and abusive language the
Church bearing fruit and increasing throughout the whole world, and in almost all places
observing no fast on the seventh day of the week, I warn him, whoever he is, to beware. For
609
To Casulanus