Mr. Gillespie, imagining that the difficulties which he had stated in his former letter,
were not satisfactorily cleared up in the answer of Mr. Edwards, addressed to him the fol-
lowing reply.
Letter from Mr. Gillespie.
“Sept. 19, 1748.
rev. and dear sir,
I had the favour of yours in spring last, for which I heartily thank you. I did not want
inclination to make you a return long ago, as I prize your correspondence, but some things
concurred that effectually prevented me, which has given me concern.
It was my desire to be informed, and my inclination to make you understand, how some
passages in your book on Religious Affections did appear to me and some others, your real
friends and well-wishers in this country, that determined me to presume to offer you some
few remarks on the passages mentioned in my former letter; and desire of further information
engages me now, with all respect, to make some observations upon some things in your
letter. I hope you will pardon my freedom, and bear with me in it, and set me right wherein
you may find me to misapprehend your meaning, or to mistake in any other respect.
You say, ‘You conceive that there is a great difference between these two things, viz. its
being a man’s duty, who is without spiritual light or sight, to believe; and its being his duty
to believe without spiritual light or sight, or to believe while he yet remains without spiritual
light or sight: it is not proper to say, it is a man’s duty to believe without faith,’ &c. Now,
dear Sir, the difference here, I am not able to conceive; for all are bound to believe the divine
xcvi
testimony and to trust in Christ, which you acknowledge; and the want of spiritual light or
sight does not loose from the obligation one is laid under by the divine command to believe
instantly on Christ, and at all season, as his circumstances shall require, nor does it excuse
him in any degree for not believing. I own that a person who has no spiritual light or sight
cannot eventually believe, if by light or sight is meant the influence or grace of the Spirit,
by which one’s mind is irradiated to take up the object and grounds of faith, so as to be
made to have a spiritual sight of Christ, and to act that grace; yet still, even when one, wants
this, it is his duty, and he is bound to believe, for we know it is a maxim, ’ability is not the
rule of duty.’ I also acknowledge, that no person who is, and always has been, without spir-
itual light or sight, is bound, nor is it his duty, to believe that he has actually believed, or to
conclude he is really a partaker of the faith of God’s elect. I have some apprehension this is
all you meant by the expressions I have noticed, and the reasoning in consequence of them;
or else certainly different ideas are affixed to words with you and among us. There is indeed
a great deal of difference betwixt its being one’s duty to believe, or to act faith, and its being
his duty to believe he has believed, or has acted divine faith; i.e. you say you apply the particle
without, respecting spiritual light or sight, to the act of believing, by which I suppose you
intend, ‘all should believe, though none do really believe, without spiritual light or sight;’ in
193
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…