To all practical purposes Public Penance was a general
institution but for a short while in the Church. But the reader
must be careful to distinguish between this Public Penance and the
private confession which in the Catholic Church both East and West is
universally practised. What Nectarius did was to abolish the
office of Penitentiary, whose duty it had been to assign public
penance for secret sin; Vide,
Thomassin. Lib. cit. Livre II. Chapitre vii.
§ xiii. where the whole matter of Nectarius’s action is
discussed. a thing wholly
different from what Catholics understand by the “Sacrament of
Penance.” It would be out of place to do more in this place
than to call the reader’s attention to the bare fact, and to
supply him, from a Roman Catholic point of view, with an explanation of
why Public Penance died out. “It came to an end because it
was of human institution. But sacramental confession, being of
divine origin, lasted when the penitential discipline had been changed,
and continues to this day among the Greeks and Oriental
sects.” Addis and
Arnold. A Catholic Dictionary; sub voce Penance, Sacrament
of. That the
reader may judge of the absolute candour of the writer just quoted, I
give a few sentences from the same article: “An opinion,
however, did prevail to some extent in the middle ages, even among
Catholics, that confession to God alone sufficed. The Council of
Châlons in 813 (canon xxxiij.), says: ‘Some assert
that we should confess our sins to God alone, but some think that they
should be confessed to the priest, each of which practices is followed
not without great fruit in Holy Church.…Confession made to God
purges sins, but that made to the priest teaches how they are to be
purged.’ This former opinion is also mentioned without
reprobation by Peter Lombard (In Sentent. Lib. iv. dist.
xvij.).”