Chapter 30.—Porphyry’s Emendations and Modifications of Platonism.
If it is considered unseemly to emend anything which Plato has touched, why did Por-
phyry himself make emendations, and these not a few? for it is very certain that Plato wrote
that the souls of men return after death to the bodies of beasts.434 Plotinus also, Porphyry’s
teacher, held this opinion;435 yet Porphyry justly rejected it. He was of opinion that human
souls return indeed into human bodies, but not into the bodies they had left, but other new
bodies. He shrank from the other opinion, lest a woman who had returned into a mule
might possibly carry her own son on her back. He did not shrink, however, from a theory
which admitted the possibility of a mother coming back into a girl and marrying her own
son. How much more honorable a creed is that which was taught by the holy and truthful
angels, uttered by the prophets who were moved by God’s Spirit, preached by Him who was
foretold as the coming Saviour by His forerunning heralds, and by the apostles whom He
sent forth, and who filled the whole world with the gospel,—how much more honorable, I
say, is the belief that souls return once for all to their own bodies, than that they return again
and again to divers bodies? Nevertheless Porphyry, as I have said, did considerably improve
upon this opinion, in so far, at least, as he maintained that human souls could transmigrate
only into human bodies, and made no scruple about demolishing the bestial prisons into
which Plato had wished to cast them. He says, too, that God put the soul into the world
that it might recognize the evils of matter, and return to the Father, and be for ever eman-
cipated from the polluting contact of matter. And although here is some inappropriate
thinking (for the soul is rather given to the body that it may do good; for it would not learn
evil unless it did it), yet he corrects the opinion of other Platonists, and that on a point of
no small importance, inasmuch as he avows that the soul, which is purged from all evil and
201
received to the Father’s presence, shall never again suffer the ills of this life. By this opinion
he quite subverted the favorite Platonic dogma, that as dead men are made out of living
ones, so living men are made out of dead ones; and he exploded the idea which Virgil seems
to have adopted from Plato, that the purified souls which have been sent into the Elysian
fields (the poetic name for the joys of the blessed) are summoned to the river Lethe, that is,
to the oblivion of the past,
“That earthward they may pass once more,
Remembering not the things before,
And with a blind propension yearn
To fleshly bodies to return.”436
434 Comp. Euseb. Præp. Evan. xiii. 16.
435 Ennead, iii. 4, 2.
436 Æneid, vi. 750, 751.
Porphyry’s Emendations and Modifications of Platonism.
461
Porphyry’s Emendations and Modifications of Platonism.