Not long after this, Petilianus, bishop of Cirta or Constantina, the most eminent theo-
logian among the Donatist divines, wrote a letter to his clergy against the Catholics, of which
Augustin managed to obtain a copy, though the Donatists used their utmost care to keep it
from him; and he replied to it in two books, written at different times,—the first in the year
400, before he was in possession of the whole letter, the remainder in 402. To the first book
Petilianus made an answer, of which we gather the main tenor from a third book written
by Augustin in reply to it. It appears to have been full of vehement abuse, and to have as-
sumed the question in dispute, that the existence of the true Church, and the catholicity of
any branch of it, depended on the purity and orthodoxy of all its ministers; so that the guilt
or heresy of any minister would invalidate the whole of his ministerial acts. Hence he argued
that Cæcilianus being the spiritual father of the so-called Catholics, and having been a
traditor, none of them could possibly have been lawfully baptized, much less rightfully or-
dained.
Augustin admits neither of his assumptions; but, leaving the guilt or innocence of Cæ-
cilianus as a point which was irrelevant (though practically the case against him utterly
broke down), he addresses himself to the other point, and argues most conclusively that all
the functions of the clergy in celebrating the rites of the Church being purely ministerial,
the efficacy of those rites could in no way depend upon the excellence of the individual
minister, but was derived entirely from Christ. Hence there was a certainty of the grace
bestowed through the several ordinances, which otherwise there could not possibly have
been, had their virtue depended on the character of any man, in whom even an unblemished
reputation might have been the fruit of a skilled hypocrisy.
The third treatise in this volume belongs to a later period, being a letter written to
Bonifacius, the Roman Count of Africa under Valentinian the Third. He had written to
Augustin to consult him as to the best means of dealing with the Donatists; and Augustin
in his reply points out to him his mistake in supposing that the Donatists shared in the errors
of the Arians, whilst he urges him to use moderation in his coercive measures; though both
here and in his answer to Petilianus we find him countenancing the theory that the State
has a right to interfere in constraining men to keep within the Church. Starting with a
forced interpretation of the words, "Compel them to come in," in Luke xiv. 23, he enunciates
principles of coercion which, though in him they were subdued and rendered practically of
little moment by the spirit of love which formed so large an element in his character, yet
found their natural development in the despotic intolerance of the Papacy, and the horrors
of the Inquisition. It is probable that he was himself in some degree misled by confounding
the necessity of repressing the violence of the Circumcelliones, which was a real offense
against the State, with the expediency of enforcing spiritual unity by temporal authority.
The Donatist treatises have met with little attention from individual editors. There is
a dissertation, De Aur. Augustino adversario Donatistarum, by Adrien Roux, published at
692
Preface.