He says that he finds
“nothing else besides the essence of the Son which
admits of the generation”; that there is no sense in his words
however, is clear to every one who hears his statement at all: the task
which remains seems to be to bring to light the blasphemy which he is
trying to construct by aid of these meaningless words. For he desires,
even if he cannot effect his purpose, to produce in his hearers by this
slackness of expression, the notion that the essence of the Son is the
result of construction: but he calls its construction
“generation,” decking out his horrible blasphemy with the
fairest phrase, that if “construction” is the meaning
conveyed by the word “generation,” the idea of the creation
of the Lord may receive a ready assent. He says, then, that the essence
“admits of generation,” so that every construction may be
viewed, as it were, in some subject matter. For no one would say that
that is constructed which has no existence, so extending
“making” in his discourse, as if it were some constructed
fabric, to the nature of the Only-begotten God This
whole passage, as it stands in Oehler’s text, (which has here
been followed without alteration,) is obscure: the connection between
the clauses themselves is by no means clear; and the general meaning of
the passage, in view of the succeeding sentences, seems doubtful. For
it seems here to be alleged that Eunomius considered the κατασκεύη
to imply the previous existence of some material, so
to say, which was moulded by generation—on the ground that no one
would say that the essence, or anything else, was constructed without
being existent. On the other hand it is immediately urged that this is
just what would be said of all created things. If the passage might be
emended thus:—ἵν᾽,
ὥσπερ ἐν
ὑποκειμένῳ
τινὶ
πράγματι
πᾶσα
κατασκεύη
θεωρεῖται, (οὐ
γὰρ ἄν τις
ἔιποι
κατασκεύασθαι
ὃ μὴ
ὑφέστηκεν),
οὕτως οἷον
κατασκευάσματι
τῇ τοῦ
μονογενοῦς
φύσει
προτείνῃ τῷ
λόγῳ τὴν
ποίησιν—we should have a comparatively clear sense—“in
order that as all construction is observed in some subject matter, (for
no one would say that that is constructed which has not existence) so
he may extend the process of ‘making’ by his argument to
the nature of the Only-begotten God, as to some product of
construction.” The force of this would be, that Eunomius is
really employing the idea of “receiving generation,” to
imply that the essence of the Only-begotten is a κατασκεύασμα: and this, Gregory says, puts him at once on a level with
the physical creation..
“If, then,” he says, “it admits of this
generation,”—wishing to convey some such meaning as this,
that it would not have been, had it not been constructed. But what else
is there among the things we contemplate in the creation which
is without being made? Heaven, earth, air, sea, everything
whatever that is, surely is by being made. How, then, comes it
that he considered it a peculiarity in the nature of the Only begotten,
that it “admits generation” (for this is his name for
making) “into its actual essence,” as though the humble-bee
or the gnat did not admit generation into itself Oehler’s punctuation seems faulty here.,
but into something else besides itself. It is therefore acknowledged by
his own writings, that by them the essence of the Only-begotten is
placed on the same level with the smallest parts of the creation: and
every proof by which he attempts to establish the alienation of the Son
from the Father has the same force also in the case of individual
things. What need has he, then, for this varied acuteness to establish
the diversity of nature, when he ought to have taken the short cut of
denial, by openly declaring that the name of the Son ought not to be
confessed, or the Only-begotten God to be preached in the churches, but
that we ought to esteem the Jewish worship as superior to the faith of
Christians, and, while we confess the Father as being alone Creator and
Maker of the world, to reduce all other things to the name and
conception of the creation, and among these to speak of that work which
preceded the rest as a “thing made,” which came into being
by some constructive operation, and to give Him the title of
“First created,” instead of Only-begotten and Very Son. For
when these opinions have carried the day, it will be a very easy matter
to bring doctrines to a conclusion in agreement with the aim they have
in view, when all are guided, as you might expect from such a
principle, to the consequence that it is impossible that He Who is
neither begotten nor a Son, but has His existence through some energy,
should share in essence with God. So long, however, as the declarations
of the Gospel prevail, by which He is proclaimed as “Son,”
and “Only-begotten,” and “of the Father,” and
“of God,” and the like, Eunomius will talk his nonsense to
no purpose, leading himself and his followers astray by such idle
chatter. For while the title of “Son” speaks aloud the true
relation to the Father, who is so foolish that, while John and Paul and
the rest of the choir of the Saints proclaim these words,—words
of truth, and words that point to the close affinity,—he does not
look to them, but is led by the empty rattle of Eunomius’
sophisms to think that Eunomius is a truer guide than the teaching of
these who by the Spirit speak mysteries Cf. 1 Cor. xiv. 2., and
who bear Christ in themselves? Why, who is this Eunomius? Whence was he
raised up to be the guide of Christians?