180 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox It,
they are the Manes,' and therefore the mother of the Lares
was named Mania; at another time, again, he maintains
that they are gods of the air, and are termed heroes; at
another, following the opinion of the ancients, he says that
the Lares are ghosts, as it were a kind of tutelary demon,
spirits of dead? men.
42. It is a vast and endless task to examine each kind
separately, and make it evident even from your religious
books that you neither hold nor believe that there is any god
concerning whom you have not? brought forward doubtful
and inconsistent statements, expressing a thousand different
beliefs. But, to be brief, and avoid prolixity,* it is enough
to have said what has been said; it is, further, too trouble-
some to gather together many things into one mass, since
it is made manifest and evident in different ways that you
waver, and say nothing with certainty of these things which
you assert. But you will perhaps say, Even if we have no
personal knowledge of the Lares, Novensiles, Penates, still
the very agreement of our authors proves their existence,
and that such a race? takes rank among the celestial gods.
And how can it be known whether there is any god, if what
he is shall be wholly unknown ?* or how can it avail even
to ask for benefits, if it is not settled and determined who
should be invoked at each inquiry?’ For every one who
seeks to obtain an answer from any deity, should of neces-
sity know to whom he makes supplication, on whom he
calls, from whom he asks help for the affairs and occasions
of human life; especially as you yourselves declare that all
the gods do not have all power, and? that the wrath and
anger of each are appeased by different rites.
1 The MS. reads manas, corrected as above by all edd. except Hild.,
who reads Manias.
? The Ms. reads effunctorum; LB. et funct., from the correction of
Stewechius ; Gelenius, with most of the other edd., def.
3 The ms. and first ed. omit non. * Lit., ** because of aversion.”
5 Lit., ** the form of their race." 6 j,e, ignorabitur et nescietur.
7 The ms. reads consolationem— for each consolation,” i.e. to comfort
in every distress.
8 The Ms. omits et.