Canon XXIX.
It is sacrilege to degrade a bishop to the rank of a presbyter; but, if they are for just cause
removed from episcopal functions, neither ought they to have the position of a Presbyter;
and if they have been displaced without any charge, they shall be restored to their episcopal
dignity.
And Anatolius, the most reverend Archbishop of Constantinople, said: If those who
are alleged to have been removed from the episcopal dignity to the order of presbyter, have
indeed been condemned for any sufficient causes, clearly they are not worthy of the honour
of a presbyter. But if they have been forced down into the lower rank without just cause,
they are worthy, if they appear guiltless, to receive again both the dignity and priesthood of
the Episcopate.
And all the most reverend Bishops cried out:
The judgment of the Fathers is right. We all say the same. The Fathers have righteously
decided. Let the sentence of the Archbishops prevail.
And the most magnificent and glorious judges said:
Let the pleasure of the Holy Synod be established for all time.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon XXIX.
He is sacrilegious who degrades a bishop to the rank of a presbyter. For he that is guilty
of crime is unworthy of the priesthood. But he that was deposed without cause, let him be
[still] bishop.
What precedes and follows the so-called canon is abbreviated from the IVth Session of
the Council (L. and C., Conc., Tom. IV., col. 550). I have followed a usual Greek method
of printing it.
Hefele.
291
This so-called canon is nothing but a verbal copy of a passage from the minutes of the
fourth session in the matter of Photius of Tyre and Eustathius of Berytus. Moreover, it does
not possess the peculiar form which we find in all the genuine canons of Chalcedon, and in
almost all ecclesiastical canons in general; on the contrary, there adheres to it a portion of
the debate, of which it is a fragment, in which Anatolius is introduced as speaking. Besides
it is wanting in all the old Greek, as well as in the Latin collections of canons, and in those
of John of Antioch and of Photius, and has only been appended to the twenty-eight genuine
canons of Chalcedon from the fact that a later transcriber thought fit to add to the genuine
canons the general and important principle contained in the place in question of the fourth
session. Accordingly, this so-called canon is certainly an ecclesiastical rule declared at
Chalcedon, and in so far a κανών, but it was not added as a canon proper to the other
twenty-eight by the Synod.
Canon XXX.
540
Canon XXX.