Section V.
Concerning the notion of Liberty, and of moral Agency.
The plain and obvious meaning of the words Freedom and Liberty, in common speech,
is The power, opportunity, or advantage, that any one has, to do as he pleases.
Or in other words, his being free from hindrance or impediment in the way of doing,
or conducting in any respect, as he wills. — And the contrary to Liberty, whatever
name we call that by, is a person’s being hindered or unable to conduct as he will,
or being necessitated to do otherwise.
If this which I have mentioned be the meaning
of the word Liberty, in the ordinary use of language; as I trust that none that
has ever learned to talk, and is unprejudiced, will deny; then it will follow, that
in propriety of speech, neither Liberty, nor its contrary, can properly be ascribed
to any being or thing, but that which has such a faculty, power or property, as
is called will. For that which is possessed of no will, cannot have any power or
opportunity of doing according to its will, nor be necessitated to act contrary
to its will, nor be restrained from acting agreeably to it. And therefore to talk
of Liberty, or the contrary, as belonging to the very Will itself, is not to speak
good sense; if we judge of sense, and nonsense, by the original and proper signification
of words.— For the Will itself is not an Agent that has a will: the power of choosing,
itself, has not a power of choosing. That which has the power of volition is the
man, or the soul, and not the power of volition itself. And he that has the Liberty
of doing according to his will, is the Agent who is possessed of the Will; and not
the Will which he is possessed of. We say with propriety, that a bird let loose
has power and liberty to fly; but not that the bird’s power of flying has a power
and Liberty of flying. To be free is the property of an Agent, who is possessed
of powers and faculties, as much as to be cunning, valiant, bountiful, or zealous.
But these qualities are the properties of persons; and not the properties of properties.
There are two things contrary to what is
called Liberty in common speech. One is constraint; otherwise called force, compulsion,
and coaction; which is a person’s being necessitated to do a thing contrary to his
will. The other is restraint; which is, his being hindered, and not having power
to do according to his will. But that which has no will, cannot be the subject of
these things.— I need say the less on this bead, Mr. Locke having set the same
thing forth, with so great clearness, in his Essay on the Human Understanding.
But one thing more I would observe concerning
what is vulgarly called Liberty; namely, that power and opportunity for one to do
and conduct as he will, or according to his choice, is all that is meant by it;
without taking into the meaning of the word, any thing of the cause of that choice;
or at all considering how the person came to have such a volition; whether it was
caused by some external motive, or internal habitual bias; whether it was determined
by some internal antecedent volition, or whether it happened without a cause; whether
it was necessarily connected with something foregoing, or not connected. Let the
person come by his choice any how, yet, if he is able, and there is nothing in the
way to hinder his pursuing and executing his will, the man is perfectly free, according
to, the primary and common notion of freedom.
What has been said may be sufficient to
show what is meant by Liberty, according to the common notions of mankind, and in
the usual and primary acceptation of the word: but the word, as used by Arminians,
Pelagians, and others, who oppose the Calvinists, has an entirely different signification.—
These several things belong to their notion of Liberty. 1. That it consists in a
self-determining power in the Will, or a certain sovereignty the Will has over itself,
and its own acts, whereby it determines its own volitions; so as not to be dependent,
in its determinations, on any cause without itself, nor determined by any thing
prior to its own acts. 2. Indifference belongs to Liberty in their notion of it,
or that the mind, previous to the act of volition, be in
equilibrio
. 3. Contingence
is another thing that belongs and is essential to it; not in the common acceptation
of the word, as that has been already explained, but as opposed to all necessity,
or any fixed and certain connexion with some previous ground or reason of its
existence. They suppose the essence of Liberty so much to consist in these things,
that unless the will of man be free in this sense, he has no real freedom, how much
soever, he may be at Liberty to act according to his will.
A moral agent is a being that is capable
of those actions that have a moral quality, and which can properly be denominated
good or evil in a moral sense, virtuous or vicious, commendable or faulty. To moral
Agency belongs a moral faculty, or sense of moral good and evil, or of such a thing
as desert or worthiness, of praise or blame, reward or punishments; and a capacity
which an Agent has of being influenced in his actions by moral inducements or motives,
exhibited to the view of understanding and reason, to engage to a conduct agreeable
to the moral faculty.
The sun is very excellent and beneficial
in its action and influence on the earth, in warming and causing it to bring forth
its fruit; but it is not a moral agent: its action, though good, is not virtuous
or meritorious. Fire that breaks out in a city, and consumes great part of it, is
very mischievous in its operation; but is not a moral Agent: what it does is not
faulty or sinful, or deserving of any punishment. The brute creatures are not moral
Agents: the actions of some of them are very profitable and pleasant; others are
very hurtful: yet seeing they have no moral faculty, or sense of desert, and do
not act from choice guided by understanding, or with a capacity of reasoning and
reflecting, but only from instinct, and are not capable of being influenced by moral
inducements, their actions are not properly sinful or virtuous, nor are they properly
the subjects of any such moral treatment for what they do, as moral Agents are for
their faults or good deeds.
Here it may be noted, that there is a circumstantial
difference between the moral Agency of a ruler and a subject. I call it circumstantial,
because it lies only in the difference of moral inducements, by which they are capable
of being influenced, arising from the difference of circumstance. A ruler, acting
in that capacity only, is not capable of being influenced by a moral law, and its
sanctions of threatenings and promises, rewards and punishments, as the subject
is; though both may be influenced by a knowledge of moral good and evil. And therefore
the moral Agency of the Supreme Being, who acts only in the capacity of a ruler
towards his creatures, and never as a subject, differs in that respect from the
moral Agency of created intelligent beings. God’s actions, and particularly those
which he exerts as a moral governor, have moral qualifications, and are morally
good in the highest degree. They are most perfectly holy and righteous; and we must
conceive of Him as influenced, in the highest degree, by that which, above all others,
is properly a moral inducement; viz. the moral good which He sees in such and such
things: and therefore He is, in the most proper sense, a moral Agent, the source
of all moral ability and Agency, the fountain and rule of all virtue and moral good;
though by reason of his being supreme over all, it is not possible He should be
under the influence of law or command, promises or threatenings, rewards or punishments,
counsels or warnings. The essential qualities of a moral Agent are in God, in the
greatest possible perfection; such as understanding to perceive the difference between
moral good and evil; a capacity of discerning that moral worthiness and demerit,
by which some things are praiseworthy, others deserving of blame and punishment;
and also a capacity of choice, and choice guided by understanding, and a power of
acting according to his choice or pleasure, and being capable of doing those things
which are in the highest sense praiseworthy. And herein does very much consist that
image of God wherein he made man, (which we read of,
Gen. 1:26, 27
, and
chap. 9:6
.)
by which God distinguished man from the beasts, viz. in those faculties and principles
of nature, whereby He is capable of moral Agency. Herein very much consists the
natural image of God; whereas the spiritual and moral image, wherein man was made
at first, consisted in that moral excellency with which he was endowed.