‘A certain cloud of romance encircled
him’ (Reynolds). His escapes from Philagrius, Syrianus, Julian,
his secret presence in Alexandria, his life among the monasteries of
Egypt in his third exile, his reputed visits to distant councils, all
impress the imagination and lend themselves to legend and fable. Later
ages even claimed that he had fled in disguise to Spain and served as
cook in a monastery near Calahorra (Act. SS. 2 Maii)! But he is also
surrounded by an atmosphere of truth. Not a single miracle of any kind
is related of him. To invest him with the halo of miracle the
Bollandists have to come down to the ‘translation’ of his
body, not to Constantinople (an event surrounded with no little
uncertainty), but to Venice, whither a thievish sea-captain, who had
stolen it from a church in Stamboul, brought a body, which decisively
proved its identity by prodigies which left no room for doubt. But the
Athanasius of history is not the subject of any such tales. It has been
said that no saint outside the New Testament has ever claimed the gift
of miracles for himself. At any rate (though he displays credulity with
regard to Antony), the saintly reputation of Athanasius rested on his life and character alone, without
the aid of any reputation for miraculous power.