AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I.
461
the Gospels, but in explaining an Apostle's meaning are unequal to themselves. Others,
although most acute in the New Testament,
are dumb in the Psalms and the Old Testa-
ment. I quite agree with Virgil — Non om-
nia possumus omnes ; and seldom or never is the rich man found who in the abundance
of his wealth has everything in equal pro-
portions. That God has given possible com-
mands, I admit no less than you. But it is
not for each one of us to make all these pos-
sible virtues our own, not because our nature
is weak, for that is a slander upon God, but
because our hearts and minds grow weary
and cannot keep all virtues simultaneously
and perpetually. And if you blame the
Creator for having made you subject to
weariness and failure, I shall reply, your
censure would be still more severe if you
thought proper to accuse Him of not having
made you God. But you will say, if I have
not the power, no sin attaches to me. You
have sinned because you have not done what
another could do. And again, he in com-
parison with whom you are inferior will be a
sinner in respect of some other virtue, rela-
tively to you or to another person ; and thus
it happens that whoever is thought to be first,
is inferior to him who is his superior in some
other particular.
24. C. If it is impossible for man to be
without sin, what does the Apostle Jude mean
by writing,' " Now unto Him that is able to keep you without sin, and to set you before
the presence of His glory without blemish " ? This is clear proof that it is possible to keep
a man withput sin and without blemish.
A. You do not understand the passage. We are not told that a man can be without
sin, which is your view, but that God, if He
chooses, can keep a man* free from sin, and of His mercy guard him so that he may be with-
out blemish. And I say that all things are
possible with God ; but that everything which
a man desires is not possible to him, and es-
pecially, an attribute which belongs to no
created thing you ever read of.
C. I do not say that a man is without sin,
which, perhaps, appears to you to be possible ;
but that he may be, if he chooses. For actual-
ity is one thing, possibility another. In the
actual we look for an instance ; possibility
implies that our power to act is real.
A. You are trifling, and forget the proverb,
" Don't do what is done." . You keep turning
in the same mire," and only make more dirt. I shall, therefore, tell you, what is clear to all,
1 Verse -24.
a Liter. il!v, w.i-,h :i l.rirk uh.it has not been burnt). Hence (i)
I.-ih nr in v.iin, i,r ( j) make bad worse. The latter appears to be the meaning here.
that you are trying to establish a thing that is
not, never was, and, perhaps, never will be.
To employ your own words, and show the
folly and inconsistency of your argument, I
say that you are maintaining an impossible
possibility. For your proposition, that a man
can be without sin if he chooses, is either
true or false. If it be true, show me who the
man is ; if it be false, whatever -is false can
never happen. But let us have no more of
these notions. Hissed off the stage, and no
longer daring to appear in public, they should
stay on the book shelves, and not let them- selves be heard.
25. Let us proceed to other matters. And
here I must speak uninterruptedly, so far, at
least, as is consistent with giving you an op-
portunity of refuting me, or asking any ques-
tion you think fit.
C. I will listen patiently, though I cannot
say gladly. The ability of your reasoning
will strike me all the more, while I am amazed at its falsity.
A. Whether what I am going to say is true
or false, you will be able to judge when you have heard it.
C. Follow your own method. I am resolved,
if I am unable to answer, to hold my tongue rather than assent to a lie.
A. What difference does it make whether
I defeat you speaking or silent, and, as it is
in the l story of Proteus, catch you asleep or awake ?
C. When you have said what you like, you
shall hear what you will certainly not like.
For though truth may be put to hard shifts it cannot be subdued.
A. I want to sift your opinions a little, that
your followers may know what an inspired
genius you are. You say, " It is impossible for any but those who have the knowledge of
the law to be without sin"; and you, conse- quently, shut out from righteousness a large
number of Christians, and, preacher of sinless-
ness though you are, declare nearly all to be
sinners. For how many Christians have that
knowledge of the law which you can find but
seldom, or hardly at all, in many doctors of
the Church ? But your liberality is so great
that, in order to stand well with your
Amazons, you have elsewhere written, " Even women ought to have a knowledge of the
law," although the Apostle preaches that women ought to keep silence in the churches,
and if they want to know anything consult
their husbands at home. And you are not
content with having given your cohort a
knowledge of Scripture, but you must delight
yourself with their songs and canticles, for
1 Virg. Georg., iv.