But let us pass on, if it seems
good, to another of his statements, and dismiss the nonsense that comes
between. He who laboriously reiterates against our argument the
Aristotelian division of existent things, has elaborated
“genera,” and “species,” and
“differentiæ,” and “individuals,” and
advanced all the technical language of the categories for the injury of
our doctrines. Let us pass by all this, and turn our discourse to deal
with his heavy and irresistible argument. For having braced his
argument with Demosthenic fervour, he has started up to our view as a
second Pæanian of Oltiseris That
is, a new Demosthenes, with a difference. Demosthenes’ native
place was the Attic deme of Pæania. Eunomius, according to S.
Gregory, was born at Oltiseris (see p. 38, note 6,
sup.)., imitating
that orator’s severity in his struggle with us. I will transcribe
the language of our author word for word. “Yes,” he says,
“but if, as the generate is contrary to the ungenerate, the
Generate Light be equally inferior to the Ungenerate Light, the one
will be found to be Reading γενήσεται light, the other
darkness.” Let him who has the leisure learn from his words how
pungent is his mode of dealing with this opposition, and how exactly it
hits the mark. But I would beg this imitator of our words either to say
what we have said, or to make his imitation of it as close as may be,
or else, if he deals with our argument according to his own education
and ability, to speak in his own person and not in ours. For I hope
that no one will so miss our meaning as to suppose that, while
“generate” is contradictory in sense to
“ungenerate,” one is a diminution of the other. For the
difference between contradictories is not one of greater or less
intensity, but rests its opposition upon their being mutually exclusive
in their signification: as, for example, we say that a man is asleep or
not asleep, sitting or not sitting, that he was or was not, and all the
rest after the same model, where the denial of one is the assertion of
its contradictory. As, then, to live is not a diminution of not
living, but its complete opposite, even so we conceived having been
generated not as a diminution of not having been generated, but as an
opposite and contradictory not admitting of any middle term, so that
which is expressed by the one has nothing whatever to do with that
which is expressed by the other in the way of less or more. Let him
therefore who says that one of two contradictories is defective
as compared with the other, speak in his own person, not in ours. For
our homely language says that things which correspond to
contradictories differ from one another even as their originals do. So
that, even if Eunomius discerns in the Light the same divergence as in
the generate compared with the Ungenerate, I will re-assert my
statement, that as in the one case the one member of the contradiction
has nothing in common with its opposite, so if “light” be
placed on the same side as one of the two contradictories, the
remaining place in the figure must of course be assigned to
“darkness,” the necessity of the antithesis arranging the
term of light over against its opposite, in accordance with the analogy
of the previous contradictory terms “generate” and
“ungenerate.” Such is the clumsy answer which we, who as
our disparaging author says, have attempted to write without logical
training, deliver in our rustic dialect to our new Pæanian. But to
see how he contended with this contradiction, advancing against us
those hot and fire-breathing words of his with Demosthenic intensity,
let those who like to have a laugh study the treatise of our orator
itself. For our pen is not very hard to rouse to confute the notions of
impiety, but is quite unsuited to the task of ridiculing the ignorance
of untutored minds.