11. This their notion then being evidently
unseemly and irrational as well as the rest, the likeness and the
oneness must be referred to the very Essence of the Son; for unless it
be so taken, He will not be shown to have anything beyond things
originate, as has been said, nor will He be like the Father, but He
will be like the Father’s doctrines; and He differs from the
Father, in that the Father is Father Cf.
Serap. i. 16. de Syn. 51. and infr. §19,
note. And so S. Cyril, cf. Or. i. 21–24, de Decr.
11, n. 6, Thesaur. p. 133, Naz. Orat. 29, 5. vid. also
23, 6 fin. 25, 16. vid. also the whole of Basil, adv. Eun. ii.
23. ‘One must not say,’ he observes, ‘that these
names properly and primarily, κυρίως καὶ
πρώτως belong to
men, and are given by us but by a figure καταχρηστικῶς
(ii. 39, n. 7) to God. For our Lord Jesus Christ,
referring us back to the Origin of all and True Cause of beings says,
“Call no one your father upon earth, for One is your Father,
which is in heaven.”’ He adds, that if He is properly and
not metaphorically even our Father (de Decr. 31, n. 5), much
more is He the πατὴρ τοῦ
κατὰ φύσιν
υἱοῦ. Vid. also Euseb.
contr. Marc. p. 22, c. Eccl. Theol. i. 12. fin. ii. 6.
Marcellus, on the other hand, said that our Lord was κυρίως
λόγος, not
κυρίως
υἱ& 231·ς. ibid. ii.
10 fin. vid. supr. ii. 19, note 3., but the doctrines and teaching are the
Father’s. If then in respect to the doctrines and the teaching
the Son is like the Father, then the Father according to them will be
Father in name only, and the Son will not be an exact Image, or rather
will be seen to have no propriety at all or likeness of the Father; for
what likeness or propriety has he who is so utterly different from the
Father? for Paul taught like the Saviour, yet was not like ‘Him
in essence κατ᾽ οὐσίαν
ὅμοιος,
Or. i. 21, n. 8..’ Having then such notions, they
speak falsely; whereas the Son and the Father are one in such wise as
has been said, and in such wise is the Son like the Father Himself and
from Him, as we may see and understand son to be towards father, and as
we may see the radiance towards the sun. Such then being the Son,
therefore when the Son works, the Father is the Worker Supr. §6., and the Son coming to the Saints, the
Father is He who cometh in the Son And
so ἐργαζομένου
τοῦ πατρὸς,
ἐργάζεσθαι
καὶ τὸν υἱ&
231·ν. In illud Omn. 1, d. Cum
luce nobis prodeat, In Patre totus Filius, et totus in Verbo Pater.
Hymn. Brev. in fer. 2. Ath. argues from this oneness of
operation the oneness of substance. And thus S. Chrysostom on the text
under review argues that if the Father and Son are one κατὰ τὴν
δύναμιν,
they are one also in οὐσία. in
Joan. Hom. 61, 2, d. Tertullian in Prax. 22. and S.
Epiphanius, Hær. 57. p. 488. seem to say the same on the
same text. vid. Lampe in loc. And so S. Athan. τριὰς
ἀδιαίρετος
τῇ φύσει, καὶ
μία ταύτης ἡ
ἐνέργεια. Serap. i. 28, f. ἓν
θέλημα
πατρὸς καὶ
υἱοῦ καὶ
βούλημα, ἐπεὶ
καὶ ἡ φύσις
μία. In illud Omn. 5.
Various passages of the Fathers to the same effect (e.g. of S. Ambrose,
si unius voluntatis et operationis, unius est essentiæ, de
Sp. ii. 12. fin. and of S. Basil, ὦν
μία ἐνέργεια,
τούτων καὶ
οὐσία μία, of Greg. Nyss. and Cyril. Alex.) are brought together in the
Lateran Council. Concil. Hard. t. 3, p. 859, &c. The subject
is treated at length by Petavius Trin. iv. 15., as He
promised when He said, ‘I and My Father will come, and will make
Our abode with him John xiv. 23.;’ for in the
Image is contemplated the Father, and in the Radiance is the Light.
Therefore also, as we said just now, when the Father gives grace and
peace, the Son also gives it, as Paul signifies in every Epistle,
writing, ‘Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord
Jesus Christ.’ For one and the same grace is from the Father in
the Son, as the light of the sun and of the radiance is one, and as the
sun’s illumination is effected through the radiance; and so too
when he prays for the Thessalonians, in saying, ‘Now God Himself
even our Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ, may He direct our way unto
you 1 Thess. iii.
11.,’ he has guarded the unity of the
Father and of the Son. For he has not said, ‘May they
direct,’ as if a double grace were given from two Sources, This
and That, but ‘May He direct,’ to shew that the Father
gives it through the Son;—at which these irreligious ones will
not blush, though they well might.